March 2009 \ Features \ 10 Best Digital Recorders for Guitarists

10 Best Digital Recorders for Guitarists

Joe Coffey

A look at 10 digital recorders that'll make your life a lot easier


Premier Guitar March 2009

Just think of how many Doobie Brothers bootlegs Rerun could’ve recorded if he would’ve had a sleek digital recorder instead of that bulky cassette recorder that got him busted. In terms of truly portable recording devices, we’ve come a long way, baby. Not only are digital recorders small enough to fit into your pocket these days, they can record at previously unfathomable quality settings. Some do a lot more, too—like add guitar effects, play back loops and give you multi-track capabilities. Here are ten that we find particularly worth the bang for their buck.

Sony PCM-D50 (Street $450)
The little brother of the PCM-D1, the PCM-D50 makes better-than-DAT recording affordable while retaining many features of its award-winning relative: X-Y or Wide electret condenser stereo mics, 4 GB internal and Memory Stick Duo memory, digital and optical lines in/ out, .WAV recording, .WAV/MP3 playback and USB connectivity. Differences include a lightweight aluminum casing (not titanium), a smaller frame, and a preamp that is only slightly less stellar. Bonus: Sonic Forge software included.
   
Roland Edirol R-09 (Street $350)
The R-09 is a workhorse that has proven dependable in live field recording situations for our staff. With 24bit/48.1kHz recording in MP3 playback, built-in stereo mics, a slot for an SD or SDHC memory card, and mic/ line inputs, the R-09 packs a lot of punch for its cigarette pack size (100’s). The updated R-09HR offers upgrades like 24bit/96kHz recording, an internal playback speaker and Cakewalk software for $400.
   
Olympus LS-10 (Street $400)
Capable of recording in .WAV, MP3 and .WMA at 24bit/96kHz, the LS-10 continues Olympus’ tradition of looking very businesslike while offering surprisingly good musical recording capability. The LS-10 performs well in amped guitar situations with careful manipulation of its simplebut- effective Low and High microphone sensitivity settings, Low Cut Filter and Zoom Mic (wide, standard, narrow, zoom)settings. Special playback settings are fun but not necessarily crucial—Reverb (Studio, Club, Hall and Dome) and Euphony (Normal, Natural, Wide, Power). Bonus: windscreens, case, strap and Cubase LE included.
   
Line 6 BackTrack (Street $100)
Our first guitar-specific digital recorder in this lineup basically takes your guitar line out and records everything you do, waiting for you to press the Mark button after you stumble upon a moment of brilliance. The device reads like a flash drive and stores up to 1GB of .WAV files at up to 24bit/48kHz and runs off a USB rechargeable battery. The upgraded BackTrack + Mic has a built-in mic, a 1/8” headphone out and 2GB of memory for $150.
   
TASCAM GT-R1 (Street $350)
Combine a 24bit/48kHz recorder (.WAV and MP3) with the concept of guitar training and you get the formidable GT-R1, a back pocket-friendly tool built for chop-building and songwriting. Plug your guitar or bass in along with your headphones and you can play with more than 80 rhythm tracks using an array of amp simulators and effects (compressor, chorus, flanger, verb, delay and more). Load some MP3 files and go to town looping sections, slowing licks while keeping pitch and overdubbing tracks. There’s also an analog limiter, a guitar and bass cancelling feature, and an EQ. Bonus: metronome and tuner. Also: 1GB SD card and rechargeable battery included.
   
Zoom H2 (Street $180)
The H2 records at 24bit/96kHz in .WAV or MP3 with a time stamping function for referencing. The quality is very good and the unit is back pocket-friendly. The W-Y or Wide pattern mics (4 capsules) allow you to capture front 90 degree cardioid, rear 120 degree cardiod and 360 degree polar patterns. Bonus: tuner and auto start. Also: mini-tripod, earbuds, wall wart, windscreen, pouch, mic clip adapter and 512MB SD card included.
   
Zoom H4 (Street $270)
The H4 is one beast of a step up from the H2. We’re talking 4-track recording, guitar and bass amp modeling, effects (chorus compression, delay) and computer interface capabilities, not to mention XLRs and auto level setting. Stereo electret cardioid condensers offer knock-out quality in an X-Y pattern. There’s also mic modeling and 48V phantom power for an external. Bonus: Tuner and metronome. Also: wall wart, windshield cover, 512 MB SD card, windscreen, tripod adapter and Cubase LE included.
   
Ovation iDea Guitar (Street $600)
Here’s a novel idea: why not build a guitar around a digital recorder? The Ovation iDea features a digital recorder (up to 192K bit/sec) in its preamp that records, plays, loops, slows playback while keeping pitch and basically gives you an all-in-one instrument for songwriting and instruction (via audio lessons and play along tracks). An aux input allows you to play along with an external source or convert any audio source to mp3. Rather than drag your guitar and a digital recorder to your favorite spot for inspiration, you’ve got it all in one package
   
Boss Micro BR (Street $230)
Traditional stand-alone multi-track recorders aren’t anything new but a few are worth including in this roundup due to their continually shrinking size. The 5 ounce Boss Micro BR can easily fit in your front pocket but still offers 4-track recording, editing and mastering with multiple inputs, amp modeling, built-in effects (distortion, chorus, verb, delay, etc.) and 293 drum patterns. Virtual tracks, time stretch, copy/ paste, an internal mic and a slew of other features allow you to literally take a powerful little studio with you anywhere. It records in MP3 and .WAV up to 16bit/44.1kHz.
   
TASCAM DP-004 (Street $200)
Two standard stompboxes wide, TASCAM’s DP-04 offers no-frills 4-track recording with dedicated knobs for inputs (2 ins and master) and playback (level and pan). Like the Micro BR, it can handle two simultaneous inputs. Overdubbing, track consolidation, autopunch and undo make editing easy and mixdown is simplified with a dedicated track. The unit records at 16bit/44.1kHz on an included 1GB SD card. At 2.8 ounces, the DP-04 is still light but is very solid. Bonus: dedicated RTZ button, jog shuttle.


     

Related Articles

Summer Survival Giveaways Day #17: Cleartone Strings
Seagull Guitars Announces New Excursion Series


Comments

(13 comments) display by
UsernameComment
Norris Mantooth
on 03/31/2010
I own the Olympus LS-10. An amazing recorder, amazing quality recording. It's lightweight and still rugged-feeling. John Mayer also uses one, as he reported on his blog.
Stu
on 09/20/2009
I waited and waited for a small digital recorder with a guitar input and a mic to be made, and the Line 6 BackTrack + Mic finally came out. read my review on the Guitar Center website. It's the first review (4 stars) on the list.
Vince
on 07/17/2009
I bought a Zoom h-4 right when they came out and am NOT tech savvy. The thing is one of the best purchases I ever made as it easy to use and sounds awesome!!!!!!!!!
Rocky
on 03/26/2009
Thnaks Rebecca that is a big help and the best answer I have recived from anyone. Tascam never replied and Guitar Center simply said they had no clue and to contact Tascam. I appreciate your effort.
Rebecca - Web Ed
on 03/26/2009
Rocky - talked to TASCAM, they said that some packages don't have a UPC, and you can just send in a section of the orange cardboard that says "GT-R1." Hope that helps!
Rocky
on 03/25/2009
As far as support for the Tascam GT-r1, they are offering a 50 dollar rebate through Guitar Center. One problem though, they require the UPC symbol from the package, the problem is there does not appear to be one and neither Guitar Center or Tascam seem to know where its located. I am waiting for Tascams reply but its been more than 24 hours. Good thing its not a real technical problem. Then I would be TSOL. I am tempted to send the unit back and get something else from another dealer altogether. Any thoughts, maybe from a Tascam Rep ro PG Mag?
John
on 03/25/2009
The Zoom H2 works quite well and is a good value IMO. Recordings sound excellent when levels are set properly. The 4 channel recording option is great for environmental surround sampling. Very portable, batteries last a decent period. Complaints include: 1) Display is too small for these old eyes. 2) Difficult to set levels properly in high-dynamic range situations. 3) Auto-record mode only works for 1 take, then you have to press the record button again.
Rick Jasonis
on 03/24/2009
I don't know what the fuss is over reading manuals. I usually read the manuals of prospective purchases (sometimes more than once) to see if the feature set is what I'm looking for. The sales descriptions don't usually get into it deep enough to really tell. After reading the manual for the GT-R1, I'm convinced it will be the one I buy (support or not). It beats the rest hands down for my purposes (I want the playback speed independent of pitch, among other things). Some of the features are a bit buried in menus, but all in all I feel it will do what I want it to. That's my bottom line. I suggest everyone read manuals if the description isn't detailed enough.
Rocky
on 03/24/2009
I just bought the The Tascam GT-r1 and just took it out of the box. My purchase was based on information I found in last months Premier Guitar. I hope what Ron says is not true, but I do have 30 days to return and if I find out its to complicated and poor quality and there is no service from the support center you bet I will. Maybe Ron should work for your magazine so we get the truth. I will think twice next time I read what appears to be an inaccurate biased review.
Ron
on 03/04/2009
The Tascam GT-r1 is a bit tricky to use. I am not sure if it is any good or not. Internal mic picks up a WHOLE bunch of background noise. It will most likely be a good unit after I spend endless hours reading the manualo.. Don,t bother E-mailing the support people re questions. They won,t reply. They get a frigging "F" for service!



Your Comment:  

All comments are subject to editing or deletion by the Premier Guitar staff.

Your Name:  


Please enter the text you see in the image:  
10

D630F407-C559-4E24-B193-826722F0AD98