March 2009 \ Gigging & Recording \ Hey, You Can't Do That \ The Economy... Of Tone!

The Economy... Of Tone!

Steve Ouimette

Getting back to basics brings you in touch with your gear


Premier Guitar March 2009

Most of us are gear nuts…why else would I be writing this and you be reading it if we weren’t? We obsess over NOS tubes, transformers, guitar weight, mustard caps, and true bypass until we’re blue in the face. We talk on forums, hang out at music stores, spend time at our friends’ houses showing off our latest acquisition and comparing notes. It’s a love affair, no question about it. But sometimes when you get this deep into something you lose sight of what brought you to it in the first place.

For those of us old enough to have witnessed music being made on simple systems with minimal gear, we can remember the immediacy and gut level emotion it hit us on. On the flipside of that, I can vividly recall the typical “back in the day” rig that was the envy of so many of us rock guitarists. It started with a perfectly good sounding but fairly basic amp (Marshall was standard) that was modified to add an extra gain stage or ten master volume, new tone stack, and an FX loop. Proudly occupying a space the size of a study carol and lit up like Las Vegas next to the four 4x12 cabs wired in stereo was a refrigerator rack full of every gadget you could imagine. Everything from digital delays to reverbs to MIDI-controlled multi-FX units was jammed into that rack and run through the FX loop.

Sadly, most of the gear back then was first-generation digital and had much lower sampling rates and lousy A/D converters compared to today, so your tone took a noise dive the second you plugged it in. And never mind the fact that you had to adjust the input and output of each of those rack units which ensured the gain staging was blown to hell by the time the signal made its way back to the FX loop return on the amp. Add to the picture the fact that with all the junk daisy-chained in the rack you needed additional units to remedy the tone-suck you created in the first place. This led to the development of a whole market of devices created to fix those problems…signal exciters to bring back the high frequencies lost, noise suppressors to stave off the hiss created by the exciters and poor quality A/Ds and D/As, and don’t forget the wireless unit to boost the signal one more time (c’mon, you know the stage was too big for a silly 20' cable, right?).

So what happened when you finally got the rig set up in all its glory? The stereo chorus spread between the cabs just right, the MIDI tap-tempo delay set for the song, the reverb dialed in to sound like you’re playing at Hedley Grange. Well? Chances are it wasn’t so great. Sure, it was chorused out, tempo-synched with the song and lush with reverb, but did it sound good? If you’re anything like me (no, my rack was more of a dorm fridge), you felt that despite your good intentions the tone fell short. In fact, it probably was missing something that you liked about the amp to begin with. What was it? It was a combination of everything that was lost by complicating the picture…kind of like an out-of-focus picture rather than a nice, sharp, clean and defined photograph. For the most part, the real tone of your rig is coming from (aside from your hands!) the guitar and the amp. The little things like speaker cables make a difference too, but just like baking, the fx are like spice…a little goes a long way. The more you complicate the picture, the less pure the end result.

Even the smallest changes to amp circuitry affect the tone. In the seventies, master volume amps became popular especially in recording studios and clubs with the advent of better PA systems. A great example of how this can change tone is on the Kiss Alive! and Alive II records. On Alive! they were using non-master volume Marshalls, whereas they moved to master volume Marshalls on Alive II. You can hear the immediacy, power and clarity on Alive! while Alive II’s sound was significantly brighter, buzzier and higher gain. If you’re not a Kiss fan, there are a million other examples of this in recordings that you can reference.

As a way of experiencing this phenomenon of simplicity, try something today. If you’re fortunate enough to own several guitars, go ahead and look them over and choose one that calls to you. Do the same with your amps if you have a few in your collection. Take a single guitar cable and plug your guitar directly into the amp. Lucky enough to have a guitar room and nobody is home for a few hours? Crank it up. Ahh, doesn’t that feel good? With nothing but a cable between your guitar and your amp, this is the definition of the economy of tone. Nothing is wasted, and it’s a wonderful thing to experience with the right combination of guitar and amp. You might find it rather addictive to feel the immediacy of the attack from your pick to the string, through the pickup and cable, right into the amp. Things like volume knobs will take on a whole new level of subtlety and guys like Jimmy Page and Carlos Santana will start making sense with their constant fiddling with the controls while playing. Finessing great tone starts with the simplest of gear and builds from there. After you’ve found that great combination of guitar and amp you can then add in a little spice here and there. Maybe it’s a pedal, maybe it’s something as simple as a different gauge of string or pick. When you’re working on that level, everything counts…every single component.

Back to basics can be a very inspiring and worthwhile pursuit. I know I’ve enjoyed it tremendously, and yes, I am still obsessed with it everyday.

     

Related Articles

5 Questions to Answer Before Buying Your Next Guitar
5 Rutbusters That Will Change The Way You Play
5 Guitar Myths - Fact or Fiction?
Giving to Get: Donate Your Gear
Now vs. Then: Was it Really Better?


Comments

(12 comments) display by
UsernameComment
The Turnstyle Te
on 01/17/2010
Turnstyle has branched off into it's own company! See us at www.turnstyleswitch.com
GuitarPhred
on 03/16/2009
The historic tones that drove us to learning how to play guitar were recorded as you describe with rare exception. I lugged half a pickup bed full of rack and cabs to every gig in the 90's. The other guitarist in the band went to guitar->cable->amp with 2 OD modes and reverb. A week later, my combo was on order and the rack system was for sale. I've sinced done the same on the guitars with the Turnstyle switch. I still carry a couple of guitars to gigs, only now it is for string breakage insurance instead of defeating the 1-trick pony syndrome. See them listed on the Custom Shop page of www.obbligatoinc.com (Blackie, Blondie and Jazz)
Funknbluezer
on 03/04/2009
The quixotic quest for tone is not high-flown or impractical but one of an almost romantic nature. Tone starts at the tips of your fingers and goes from there.
Ron Lovelace
on 03/02/2009
If you were to take your present thoughts back a bit further, I can remember when we thought plugging into am amp that had onboard reverb was a big thing. Heck, you could plug into one side with the microphone and the other with your guitar, with reverb on one or the other. Talk about getting your kicks. Sometimes simple is better.
david yim
on 02/26/2009
good advice ..... after getting to know the economy of tone, the addition/subtraction of pedals makes more tonal sense ......
Steve Ouimette
on 02/25/2009
Gonzo, you're absolutely correct about the right sized amp. I actually talk about that in my attenuator article this month. 3 or 5 watts is more than enough for home playing on a tube amp. In fact, you can get away with 1 watt as we've seen on some boutique amps that are being built now. So very true...100 watts in the house is totally useless.
Mike Ryan
on 02/25/2009
Good article. My main rig consists of a Soldano SLO 100 with a Marshall 2X12 (EV loaded)and for bigger stages a 4X12 (Also EV loaded)with a switchable FX rack(14 space)that also contains a back up amp rig. I have never had a problem with any of it, tone, volume issues or breakdown. For recording and little sit-in gigs and jams, I use a Blues Jr that I modded the tone stack, bias resistor, power supply, and stuck a JBL E-120 in there. Guitars go straight through a Mogami cable to the little amp. Works and sounds awesome. Tone for days. Those JR's are quite a killer little amp. Hard to believe it is only 15 watts........loud as hell! Sometimes, I will put a Korg Pandora (the first series) between the Guitar and the Jr, get a nice clean tone, and use the Pandora for a lite crunch and effects tone. Still sounds wonderful.........a little goes a long way with effects anyway, right? Thanx, Mike
RAFAEL BONILLA
on 02/25/2009
IT TOOK ME 12 YEARS AND I FELT SO SORRY TO SELL MY PEDALS FOR A RACK UNIT (DAMN IT!) NOW I FEEL VERY AFORTUNATE TO HAVE ENOUGH GUITARS AND AMPS TO CHOOSE IN MY STUDIO AND MAKE THIS EXERCISE !! GREAT ARTICLE.
jay
on 02/25/2009
I have recently started playing out again here in Hawaii. I have a truck load of pedals and such and they just muddy up the works. I have found my absolute favorite sound is my HRDLX, a Strat, or my PRS McCarty, a cable and just play.

Simple, powerful, and tasty. He speaks the truth.
Gonzo
on 02/25/2009
I would add having the right sized amp. Let's face it, 100w of tube power is more than most of us will ever need. 50w is still probably overkill for most. You'll get a much better tone out of a tube amp working within its "zone" than getting some overpowered beast and playing it at 1 or 2 all the time.



Your Comment:  

All comments are subject to editing or deletion by the Premier Guitar staff.

Your Name:  


Please enter the text you see in the image:  
10

64E0087D-26E7-4EDB-B85C-000151609467