July 2010 \ Tech Tips \ Get Wired \ String Myths, Part 1

String Myths, Part 1

Wallace Marx Jr.

Do thicker strings make you a better player?


Premier Guitar July 2010

Stevie Ray Vaughan’s influence on gear and gearheads has been gigantic. Back in the ‘80s, it seemed as if he almost single-handedly resurrected the Stratocaster, helping boost vintage Strats into a mythic realm. And who else did more to bring the worship of vintage Fender amps to a whole new level?

In one of his earliest major interviews, around 1983, Stevie Ray Vaughan let out a bit of personal information that has had an effect on gear and gearheads to this day. Talking about his now well-known ‘59 Strat—even then completely trashed—he told the interviewer what string gauges he was using: .013 to .052. The interviewer was surprised and asked him to repeat it. Yep, 13s. I remember reading that interview as a teenager and my jaw dropping.

No one used strings that thick. But now that Stevie Ray did, it started to creep into the consciousness. Thus became the mantra, myth, truth, cliché—whatever you want to call it—in strings: heavier is better. Surely, heavy strings produce better tone. And, surely, only a great player will be able to handle the thicks. So, it follows that if I play heavy strings I am great. The debate goes on. You hear it all the time. “Anybody tried 12s?”

Some myths are meant to be explored, so let’s look at some of the great players and the gauge strings they used. Starting with Stevie Ray, we find that, according to most available published information, he did indeed play some of the heaviest gauges available, most consistently 13s. He even went thicker, an astounding .018-.072 at one point. However, on the brown ‘63 Strat known as Lenny, SRV switched to lighter strings to get a lighter tone. Some nights when his fingers were thrashed he’d go down as light as 11s—back into mere mortal territory. It was rumored that he went to lighter strings later in his life, but I haven’t been able to substantiate this.

Swing to another god of guitar, James Marshall Hendrix, undisputed King of Gigantic Tone. One might assume that from gigantic strings come gigantic tone, but check this little tidbit from the absolute must-have book Jimi Hendrix: Musician by Keith Shadwick: “Hendrix described the setup on his Strat around 1967 as ‘Fender light-gauge strings, using a regular E-string for the B and sometimes a tenor A-string for a [high] E to get my kind of sound on the Stratocaster. [I] put the strings on with a slightly higher [action] so they can ring longer.’ This particular string-swapping routine was a popular modification at the time. It resulted in a set of stings as light as possible, aiding not only the string bending but also finger vibrato. On a later guitar, his black Strat, the surviving strings indicate he preferred ‘light’ gauges, .009" to .038".”

Now go back to the roots. Early on in rock history, flatwounds were all there were. It wasn’t until 1959 when Ernie Ball put together his first sets that you could get some medium or light-gauge strings. Here’s another mind- blower: until guys like Ernie Ball came around, aspiring string-benders like Chuck Berry found a secret weapon—banjo strings. Yes, that ultimate rock tone that Chuck Berry got on songs like “Johnny B. Goode,” “School Days,” and “Sweet Little 16” was derived from 8-gauge or lower banjo strings.

Some more:
  • Jimmy Page: well-known user of 8-gauge strings. 
  • Danny Gatton: played 10s with a wound G, also played 9s.
  • Jeff Beck: “On my early stuff, I was playing the thinnest strings you could get, .008s,” Beck told Fender.com. “And then the Jimi man came along and told me, ‘You can’t play with those rubber bands. Get those off there.’ So my string gauges have been creeping up ever since. Now I’ve got .011, .013, .017, .028, .038, and .049. I’m trying to get heavier on the top end.”
  • Billy Gibbons: hipped to light-gauge 8s or 9s by B.B. King. King’s take on it is that it takes a lot less stress and strain to play the light stuff. Gibbons’ custom set from Dunlop has a 7-gauge high E!
  • Brian Setzer: 10s straight out of the box.
  • Peter Frampton: 8s back in the Comes Alive days.
  • Carlos Santana: 9s
  • Allan Holdsworth: 11s
  • Eddie Van Halen: well-known for using 9-gauge.
  • James Hetfield: .009-.042
As you can see, a lot of the great players of our time have used some pretty everyday-player gauges. This is not to say that heavy strings don’t produce a different tone. The point is that the gauge of your strings is not the gauge of your greatness.

Back in the ’80s when I read that SRV interview, I immediately went out and got a set of 13s put on my yellow ’79 hardtail Strat. The guy at the store looked at me oddly, wondering what I was up to. What I was up to was sticking my nose where it didn’t belong. What I failed to remember was that Stevie Ray was a pro playing at a pro level. He played gigs every night for years to get to the point where he needed 13s. Needed, not wanted. Because of the style he had developed and the level he was playing at, SRV had to have those strings to get through the gig. Other strings would break under the strain and not produce the tonal heights he was looking for. Me? I was just a kid playing in my bedroom. When I got the Strat home with the 13s on it, I plugged it into my Peavey Classic 2x12 and tried—really tried— to play “Love Struck Baby.” Didn’t happen. I could barely chord with those monsters, let alone bend. Lesson learned.


Wallace Marx Jr. is the author of Gibson Amplifiers, 1933– 2008: 75 Years of the Gold Tone. He is a lifelong musician and has worked in all corners of the music industry. He is currently working on a history of the Valco Company. He is a children’s tour guide at the Museum of Making Music, a struggling surfer, and he once hung out with Joe Strummer.

     

Related Articles

Must We Restore?
Small Builders with Big Problems
Strings, Strings, and More Strings
Putting the Hex On: the Postmodern Pickups
The Pickup Story, Part III: The Road to the Humbucker


Comments

(20 comments) display by
UsernameComment
Kaymack
on 05/21/2013
I find that after 35 years of playing using the lightest strings I can eliminates the barrier of the instrument allowing free thought transfer without having to take in to consideration the physical make up of the guitar.
Quintin Arnold
on 05/16/2013
I certainly don't see how people like hendrix were using such light a gauge. I sadly have been using 10 hybrids (10 set on the high end,11 gauge on the lows) then on a whim baught 12 gauges for my ibanez and since then i'm putting the 12 gauges (jazz set) on my fender and getting DDT's (13 highs- 65 lows) for my ibanez, since I use it primarily for deep tunings. Playing has gotten so easy for me, I can barely even develop calluses anymore, and i play at least one hour a day, if not more. So how can people that play far better than I do not have this same problem? especially when their music sounds so deep.
kevin morris
on 03/27/2013
I'm old enough to remember getting light strings by using a banjo octave string on top e then moving the guitar e string onto b and so on. It felt a lot easier to play. For a brief period, I went down to strings with an 8 on top, but over the years, I've gone back up again. Nowadays I play with a 12 on top and a wound third. The tone is so much better, and it is much easier to play because when you hit a string to fret it, it doesn't move. That means greater accuracy. Another fact about heavier strings is that if you use them you can get the action lower. I found this article because I was searching the web for a source of good quality heavy gauge strings. Sadly, most sellers seem to think 11 tops are heavy gauge.
Bob's Your Uncle
on 02/22/2013
SRV also tuned the guitar a step lower. That makes the tension lower too.
teleman4444
on 02/12/2013
Load of BS on here. I was actually born when SRV was playing, so yes i sore him live, He used 13s early on with a heavy low end,then in 87 onwards it was 12s with heavey top, and sometimes an 11 with heavey top when fingers were smashed, he used 18s very early on, but that is never going to last for his style of playing, the other dude who uses thick strings, well he is not bending a lot, he is more classical jazz, easy with heavey strings, blues is hard as f u c k, metal is also easy with 12s, blues is one of the hardest styles for 13s
Joshua
on 01/20/2013
If you are using 8s or 9s, the very next string size is a 13. The vast majority of the tension rides on the two low strings. Once you are above 50 on those, you will have to have guitar god fingers to do any kind of vibrato. With all that tension, vibrato might even be achieved through finger pressure alone (possible, never tried). Most people out there settle on 10s or modified (custom) 9s. I dislike anything below a 10 for top string and anything heavier than 46 for a bottom. That's just how I roll. I don't do crazy vibrato technique and I like to feel an actual string beneath my fingers. Even as an early player I only used 9s for a few months. 11s feel great but too much tension if you are tuned to E. Dropped D or lower with 11s would probably be good. Go with what feels good to start with, then go up one size. Go to a midway custom size if possible when changing. Once it feels too strong, back down to the level you were using before the change. That is your gauge.
Bob Wilson
on 10/05/2012
I have been playing an archtop as my #1 for the last 15yrs, tuned a whole step down<for my voice>, and always experimented with thicker strings on it... generally .12 or .13 to about a .66..work best.they play easy and work for that guitar...my tele usually has 10's or 11's.my strat sounds good with .009's, tho they break really easy...i guess it's different strokes for different folks.. tone is in the fingers...ask Jeff Beck...
Joshua Cox
on 07/08/2012
ght to you. Do what feels good. If you think it might work, try it out. And don't be locked into a certain gauge because its normal for that style. If you play metal, that doesn't mean you cant play 12's, or if you play blues, that doesn't mean you cant play 8's. Any ways, thanks go out to Stevie Ray Vaughan for helping me find my true tone! =)
Joshua Cox
on 07/08/2012
I agree with you totally; it all depends on the player. I'm 18 and I've been playing for about 5 years, mostly blues. I started out playing a Strat with 9's, then to a Les Paul with 10's, searching for a heavier tone. The Les Paul served me well for 2 or 3 years but started to feel really stale. I felt like I got really lazy because the humbuckers were so hot and the action was so low; it was way too easy to make it scream. The tone was way too aggressive for the kind of sound I wanted. So I started playing my Strat again, but put 10's on it. Still didn't sound right. Then about 5 months ago after listening to a lot of SRV, I went up to 11's just to try it out, and it was like magic. The tone became really thick and the thickness of the strings matched how hard I like to hit them; I forgot that I was was playing single coils because it sounded so heavy. Since then I've never broken a set of 11's, only once did I break an A string, but I had that set on there for like four days, which is pretty long for me; I like to change strings every 1-2 days, because I play so much. Tuning to Eb has also made things sound way better to me too; it also makes singing easier for me, being a bass-baritone. It's just thicker, darker and intense. I really like having to fight the guitar. I'm also a really big fan of high action now, because it makes me focus more on the notes I'm playing. I like having a speed bump to control myself, because without it I just start to forget about everything and start playing as fast as possible which just doesn't give me the same satisfaction. That being said, fast playing still gets me off, as long as I put it in the right spots. After five months with bigger strings, I've never been happier, and I can't look back. As time goes on and my hands get stronger I might get bored again and move up to 12's so my guitar can keep up with me. In conclusion, I believe that string gauge, whether its lighter, heavier, or in between, depends on what feels ri
Griff
on 05/27/2012
Heavier, or lighter could affect your greatness. It just depends on what works best for you. When you find that, you may still not be great, but you'll be better. If you just do nothing, you'll never know. So, experiment!



Your Comment:  

All comments are subject to editing or deletion by the Premier Guitar staff.

Your Name:  


Please enter the text you see in the image:  
10

BAA6778E-2A3D-4D90-8AF3-07DFA4C3D9CD