July 2010 \ Gigging & Recording \ Guitar Tracks \ Why Not Leave Some Space?

Why Not Leave Some Space?

Forrest Powell

Play less, leave space, and listen to the results


Premier Guitar July 2010

An epiphany struck me from a rather unusual source recently: a guitar pedal. I never would have realized this critical and fundamental thing were it not for a Blues Brother-esque trade that I made. Okay, it wasn’t a car for a microphone, but I’m still going to use the metaphor.

I recently traded a slew of gear for, well, a slew of gear with a fellow guitarist at work—the trade included everything from an older iPhone and Mackie Onyx mixer to a $400 keyboard stand. Thankfully, the exchange reunited me with a long-lost favorite, the Boss DD-3 Digital Delay pedal. After a few days (and after I realized that one can never own too many 9-volt batteries), I plugged it into my AC15 and just sat noodling for hours. It was during this session that I couldn’t help but notice how the timing and tone for each note became crucial because I was hearing it repeat four or five times.

You know how it goes. Two seconds back on the proverbial bike again, and you recall old songs or patterns you played, which only that specific piece of gear lets you make. It might be a Rat, a Strat, or a Jazzkat, but if you’re reading this, odds are there’s a piece of gear in particular that inspired you to find new sounds that became verses, that were in turn the basis for an entire song. The DD-3 was my muse for years, and it has been again over the past few months.

And here’s why: One of the inevitabilities of delay pedals is that you’ll be either entirely encumbered by them or you’ll be forced to learn how to have some reserve with your playing. As a guitarist, I struggle with what I’ve found to be a relatively common dilemma: I don’t need to play all of the notes in the song all of the time. Whether you’re in a band or not, this applies, and I would challenge you to tell me that space doesn’t determine quite a bit of how your tone sounds.

Anecdotally, I was plugged into Guitar Rig or some such modeler the other day, and was adjusting the amount of reverb (the amount of room). It is simply incredible what the difference is between hearing this when you palm mute a note and when you just strum straight through a verse. It’s absolutely night and day, and this tells me that (again) silence is still gold en, perhaps nearly as important as the notes being played, the order they are played in, etc.

Famous orchestral conductor Leopold Stokowski once said, “Musicians paint their pictures on silence.” A blank canvas is what we start with in most artistic mediums, and having done a good bit of recording of bands and solo acts over the past several years, I think it’s safe to say that the ear can be just as lazy as the eye. What I mean by that is our ears can lose the faculty for detail, especially while we are being bombarded with all things over-filled, over-compressed, and over-the-top. This isn’t to be negative or to beat the worn-down drum of “music these days sucks,” but really, take a listen to Elgar, to Bon Iver, or put on “Since I’ve Been Loving You” and tell me that they need “more.” Less is already great.

And more will make your DD-3 sound like @#$%.

So why not leave some space?

It tends to

draw attention

to certain things.

As a matter of course, we’ve probably all played too many notes at one time or another. This limits the other instruments in the band, or the vocal part’s dynamics, or even the song’s ability to change and to stay interesting. Go outside of your genre and listen to how carefully orchestrated a symphony has to be. You might have a particular instrument take a four-measure pause with only the most nuanced stroke at a certain moment that triggers an emotional response. Nothing else would do—that’s silence for you.

Give this a shot: play the music, not the instrument.


Forrest Powell is a Sales Engineer at Sweetwater, a consultant, a producer, a songwriter and an audio engineer. He has worked on independent albums with bands and solo acts since 2000, and is currently recording a project for Andrew Gamez.

     

Related Articles

DAW Wars and More
Keeping the Peace, Pt. 3
The Road Guitarist's Studio
The Right Mic, Part 1
Blending Bass With Acoustic Guitar


Comments

(6 comments) display by
UsernameComment
Mike St Charles
on 09/21/2010
Amen, Forrest. Thank you for bringing into immediate focus the thoughts I've been having while playing with my "team." I'd like to take this a step further and not only apply this to me and my guitar, but also to restrain the vocalist who habitually fills empty rhythms and the final stanza with a vocal "tag!" Perhaps music is an area where Wayne Gretzky's quote does NOT apply: "You miss 100% of the shots you dont take"(can't accuse me of being deep)
Les Noland
on 08/16/2010
Great article. I'd heard similar advice in the past but never really took it to heart until I heard the song "Going for the One" by Yes. In that song there is a section where the band is rocking along and then suddenly there's a hole -- for one beat of song the whole band just stops. They repeat that two or three times and I couldn't believe how powerful it was to hear silence used that way. While it doesn't always have to be as dramatic as that, I understand now that the gaps, pauses, and dynamics are all as important as the notes in making great music. Thanks for the reminder.
Vince
on 07/13/2010
Thanks for the article. It's a good reminder to us all.
Kage
on 07/07/2010
Thanks for the reminder man ! I really cant hear this enough. Although I know it to be true - i seem to constantly be drawn to play too much or add too much to the mix. I suffer from "shredders syndrome" where the concept is - the more notes you can play in a measure - the better you are. I think i need to get that quote tattooed on my forearm so i can see it while iI play - "play the music not the instrument" . Thanks Forrest !!
gregg
on 07/02/2010
music is the space between the notes!!
Glenn
on 06/17/2010
Love the article, totally agree on the "less is more " vibe and I do feel that when the guitar sits out you can hear the nuances of the vocal more, everything seems to breathe better. The symphony reference was good too, the emotional response of parts etc. Thanks for the article.



Your Comment:  

All comments are subject to editing or deletion by the Premier Guitar staff.

Your Name:  


Please enter the text you see in the image:  
10

E4DD8734-58CA-478D-B0D0-664CC25CF4D0