April 2011 \ Reviews \ Media Review \ CD Review: Various Artists - "SIN-atra"

CD Review: Various Artists - "SIN-atra"

Joe Coffey

Glenn Hughes, Devin Townsend, Ripper Owens, and Dee Snider take on Sinatra classics


Premier Guitar April 2011

Various Artists
SIN-atra
Armoury Records


Ready for some metal versions of Frank Sinatra classics? Glenn Hughes, Devin Townsend, Ripper Owens, and Dee Snider are among the 12 notable artists lending their vocal talents to songs like “I’ve Got You Under My Skin,” “New York, New York,” “Witchcraft,” and “It Was a Very Good Year.” Unfortunately, some stellar vocal performances and righteous guitar and bass riffery by Bob Kulick, Richie Kotzen, and Billy Sheehan end up falling flat due to the project’s humor-bent focus and the use of keyboards. I get the dilemma—you can’t just delete Nelson Riddle horn lines and string swells from something paying tribute to Sinatra. Regardless, the keyboard tones simply kill this otherwise brave mashup, grating on your skull much like the brass-mocking keyboard in Europe’s “The Final Countdown.” Too bad. Some moments of legit darkness that breathe interesting new life into these charts get overshadowed by all the cheese.

     

Related Articles

Book Review: "My First Guitar: Tales of True Love ..."
Album Review: Mike Keneally - "Wing Beat Fantastic"
CD Review: Mastodon - "Live at the Aragon"
CD Review: Joe Bonamassa - "Dust Bowl"
CD Review: Horseback - "The Invisible Mountain"


Comments

(1 comment) display by
UsernameComment
Cheez E Cheesum
on 04/13/2011
I couldn't listen to this, I'm lactose intolernant. The cheese would kill me.



Your Comment:  

All comments are subject to editing or deletion by the Premier Guitar staff.

Your Name:  


Please enter the text you see in the image:  
10

AB59BA18-E1DC-47DE-9369-566A523C3BE4