April 2012 \ Features \ Roundup: 5 Hand-Held Multitrack Recorders Reviewed

Roundup: 5 Hand-Held Multitrack Recorders Reviewed

James Rotondi

We evaluate the features, audio quality, and design of five of the leading portable recorders to give you a leg up on tracking your guitars on the move.


Premier Guitar April 2012

(1 of 5)

While much of the buzz in the mobile recording market of late has revolved around iPhones and iPads [see our cover story, March 2012], portable stand-alone multitrack devices have quietly gotten better and better, while offering a more stable and arguably higher-performance platform than their smart-phone counterparts. What’s more, the field is awesomely varied: Some devices, like the Korg SOS, combine multitracking with onboard effects and jamming tools, while others, like the Olympus LS-100, add multitrack options to their solid footing as pro field recorders.

In this roundup, we’ll look at the Korg and Olympus units, as well as the latest incarnations of two of the most popular devices in this category—Zoom’s feature-rich H4N and Boss’ smartly designed Micro BR, both of which boast amp and pedal models, as well as worthy master effects. Finally, we’ll catch up with home-recording pioneers Tascam, and their simple, classic-looking DP-004. In every case, you’ll encounter advantages that these dedicated units have over iPhone or iPad setups, including vastly longer battery life, quality built-in microphones, better output levels, independent level controls, slick ergonomics, USB ports for connection to a computer, up to 24-bit/96kHz audio, and expandable storage capacities by way of SD or Micro SD cards.

Just don’t expect to take a call from your mom on one of these babies.

Korg SOS

• Light, truly “palm-sized” recorder with stripped-down menu set.
• “Sound On Sound” overdubbing makes for unlimited track count.
• Massive range of drum patterns and amp/effect models.

Ratings

Pros:
Clever workflow, good models, easy navigation.

Cons:
Mics are not field-recorder quality, but great for demos.

Audio Quality:

Function/Design:

Materials:

Value:

Street:
$145

Korg
korg.com

Not much bigger than a smartphone, the Korg SR-1 SOS ($145, street) combines a light, streamlined physical design with an inspired concept: Instead of the typical multitrack system, it “thinks” in terms of infinite overdubbing—the way one might approach capturing sound in a looping environment. With its ramped profile, the jet-black SOS sits on your desktop with its front panel at a slight angle toward you, like a proper mixing desk. And that front panel not only contains a 1" LED display, but also the SOS’ built-in stereo microphone and speakers, along with the main function, menu, and transport controls. Small pads on the back panel—which stores the two-AA battery compartment—keep the SOS from slipping around, while stereo mini input jacks for mic and line in, a stereo mini headphone/line out, and a ¼" jack for guitar can be found on the right side. A MicroSD card slot and 4.5V AC jack are on the left.

Much as you might use a tiny Dictaphone to capture the very first impulse of a song idea, you can use the SOS’s built-in mic to capture that vocal idea in stereo with a quality reverb, and then throw down some quick harmony ideas. No worries if you screw up—the easy undo function will wipe out as many past clunkers as you choose from the arrangement. Using one of the 200 drum tracks as a tempo guide, you can also record guitar with one of the SOS’s 100 amp/effect models. (While overdubbing, you can loop subsections of your song to record over, or simply overdub to the entire song.) That looping-type approach adds a certain casual feel to the SOS, so you may surprise yourself with adventurous, off-the-cuff stuff that you’d be unlikely to try in a stiffer recording environment—and that’s good. For such a simple device, the SOS does have something of a learning curve (lots of menus to master), but once you get the hang of it, the SOS genuinely cuts the lag time between inspiration and execution.


   1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5    Next »

Related Articles

Summer Survival Giveaways Day #18: Dunlop
Walrus Audio Hosts Relief Fund for Oklahoma Tornado Victims
Roundup: 5 Multi-Track Digital Recorders Reviewed
MXR Custom Badass '78 Distortion Pedal Review
Rivera Metal Shaman Pedal Review


Comments

(7 comments) display by
UsernameComment
Bill
on 10/30/2012
You people have a major terminology-confusion. A two-track recorder is called STEREO. A MULTITRACK is MORE THAN TWO. It is silly and grossly unprofessional to call a stereo dictaphone multitrack recorder.
Dave
on 04/02/2012
It appears that Olympus released the LS-100 without doing the sort of testing needed for this unit as a multi-track recorder. The user reviews by the video/audio users give it glowing praise. But when reading (harder to find) musician's comments on some forums you read about problems with latency during monitoring. I was all ready to buy this unit, but I'll proceed very very cautiously looking for more musically oriented reviews.
Jim Curtis
on 03/27/2012
I love my BR-80!!!! I use it to record our practice sessions and then practice with the sessions whenever I feel like it. I agree about the case; but, I think a "stand" on the back would be just as important. When we practice, it is hard to find a position that will give the best recording: hence, the stand would allow you to direct it in such a way as to customize your recording. I don't know much about recording and wish the for more educational materials on the unit and recording in general.
80's boy
on 03/24/2012
No offense to these Hand-Held Multitrack Recorders but the Zoom H1 is $90, runs on one AA battery, records stereo and sounds fantastic. Put it in your guitar case and take it anywhere. Record jams or song ideas and put them into your PC and you're ready to rock. I have one and love it.
another daniel
on 03/24/2012
Thanks so much for writing these reviews. I needed them. One thing I'm very curious about: Do you (anyone else reading this) have any input on how easily any of these upload tracks onto a computer? In my experience, I'm never able to know exactly what to expect because that info is very often not accurately described on product sites, descriptions, reviews. I had horrible experiences with a (now dated) BR-864 multitrack. Even my tech-savvy friends couldn't figure out the issue, I lost so much music.
Daniel
on 03/22/2012
I do own the Zoom, the boss and the tascam (along some other multitrackers. kind of a fan). I find myself using the DP004 most of all. Just a preference. I do favor the Zoom when in the field, for recording gigs, or practices, but when recording demos or reference tracks, that tascam kicks some serious behinds. Don't really appreciate onboard effects or amp sims, not just yet, they're close to the tone you want, but not just yet.
Renaldo
on 03/21/2012
I just bought the Apogee MIC, and I can tell you, combined with the new iPad and Garageband, these dedicated recorders don't stand a chance in comparison. The Apogee, with a full digital interface, is nothing short of jaw-dropping quality, at least for a portable field mike. Garageband is a joy to use in terms of simplicity, and provides a wide range of functions for mobile recording. The combination of the Apogee and the new iPad will be a game changer, no question.



Your Comment:  

All comments are subject to editing or deletion by the Premier Guitar staff.

Your Name:  


Please enter the text you see in the image:  
10

916C7776-F9B4-4402-A122-6410E7759DE0