August 2012 \ Features \ Amps \ Champions of Chime: The EL84 Roundup

Champions of Chime: The EL84 Roundup

Three studio pros test nine EL84-powered amps in the 15-watt ballpark.


Premier Guitar August 2012

(7 of 10)

Goodsell Super 17 Black Line


Specs

Format: 1x12 combo
Watts: 17
Preamp Tubes: Three 12AX7s
Rectifier: GZ34
Controls: Volume, tone, gain, reverb, depth, and speed knobs
Speaker: RG-65
Price: $1,499 street
superseventeen.com

Richard Goodsell knows how to build great low- to medium-wattage amps, and though he’s made the most waves building unique interpretations of unusual circuits by Watkins, Valco, Supro, and Univox, the Super 17 trades in more familiar vintage-AC15-like tones.

Locke: This sounds a lot like a real vintage AC15. It’s very tight sounding. One of the things that you look for in an EL84 amp is the compression—the way that, when you hit it, it sort of attacks and then clamps onto what you play and blooms like a compressor in the studio would—and this amp is very good at that. With my hollowbody Gibson 330, there’s a lot of contrast between pickups without getting too bright or muddy on either.

The tremolo is a nice footswitchable feature. I only had the depth about halfway up, and it was really deep—there’s quite a sweep on the depth and speed knobs. I don’t use reverb amps very often—and you don’t often see reverb on EL84 amps—but it’s cool to have and you can get a cool surf sound out of it. It also packs a lot of punch for its physical size. It’s a very efficient little amp—a very powerful 17 watts and a good buy.

Derrico: I think what I like most about the Goodsell is the tremolo, it’s really organic sounding. I like how deep it is. Even though I didn’t have the depth all the way up, it was nice. It reminded me of something I could use if I were doing a Norah Jones song. The reverb is really nice and natural, as well. It’s a tiny amp, and it’s really loud for how small and light it is— and it looks killer, too.

Trovato: This small amp has a gain stage and a volume that I tend to push to the maximum. And the gain has to go way up before things really distort, but it sounds really good. I always like to set an amp up for the best clean sound and add any kind of gain or distortion using a pedal, so this amp would work well.

When I turn off the tremolo, I can hear this subtle pulsing through a hum on the amplifier. I think this amp is a little light or small sounding, and might not be quite loud enough or powerful enough to get over a drummer in a live band situation. I think it’s perfect for home recording, though.


« Previous    1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10    Next »

Related Articles

Humphrey Espresso 15 Acoustic Amp Review
Tone King Sky King Amp Review
Humphrey Espresso 15 Acoustic Amp Review
VHT Special 12/20 RT Amp Review
Dr. Z Maz 8 Studio Amp Review


Comments

(24 comments) display by
UsernameComment
KokDestructi r
on 08/16/2012
This article makes me wanna drop my kok-n-balz into a blender..... ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
JoJo
on 08/13/2012
I think the Carvin v3m would have been a good review. At that price point, its hard to beat.
Dr Mark
on 08/13/2012
did no one bring a tuner to these sessions? Great playing guys but a couple of times, esp that SG with the vibrola ( I know they are hard to keep in tune but come on) and I agree Yoda, let's get a review of the Gabriel voxer in there.
Rick/hayward ,Ca.
on 08/05/2012
Good comments ,,,Gents.."Bob" that Gibson Gold tone or the Suhr Kelley interests the Amp/Hell outta me...Forgetaboutit.. NY....style........ ...we`re all pals here(and you guy`s too oversea`s-dont be shy....any one picks on you for engrish is a loser)..........
michael
on 07/30/2012
I sure like your reviews, But would like more clean tones and also would like to see you folks do a group of 6V6 amps and a group of Amps that are great clean foundations for pedals-Pedals have come so far from " Back in the day " It seems like there is a real run on the EL 84 stuff and it get's reviewed a lot, It would be nice to see what else is out there-
Surferbell
on 07/26/2012
My IPad speakers don't do these amps justice. I'll have to listen later with my monitors. Great post nice to have some sound to go with the article. Thanks guys!
nigeldaddy
on 07/26/2012
love the sound of the Carr. sounds like two amps at the same time- one clean, and one w/a bit of breakup. that said, i still love my genz benz black pearl for my chime needs.
tubetwang
on 07/26/2012
dr.z and vox are the best buys...
Brian Gerhard
on 07/26/2012
you can't tell which comment is about which amp, as they're the same comments on every amp???
Chime Fan
on 07/26/2012
Great, great amp. It's no wonder that all 3 players really liked it. And you can tell its an amp designed by players too. 65 Amps has done a killer job of creating an amp where you just need a guitar and a cord!



Your Comment:  

All comments are subject to editing or deletion by the Premier Guitar staff.

Your Name:  


Please enter the text you see in the image:  
10

B2A8286A-0A2B-4E4F-8529-FC6DB8355128