January 2013 \ Features \ 5 Basses Under a Grand: Fender, G&L, Ibanez, Shecter, Sterling by Music Man

5 Basses Under a Grand: Fender, G&L, Ibanez, Shecter, Sterling by Music Man

Dave Abdo and Steve Cook

Whether you’re an intermediate player who’s recently outgrown your first instrument, a weekend warrior looking for an inspiring new bass, a gigging pro looking for a dependable backup—or even if you’re primarily a guitarist who needs a solid 4-string for home-studio work—this group of quality instruments will satisfy on many, many accounts.


Premier Guitar January 2013

(1 of 5)

It’s pretty damn incredible how much bass you can get for well under a grand these days. Solid hardware appointments, quality electronics, and excellent playability straight out of the case are no longer just descriptors for pricey instruments. With advanced manufacturing methodology and much more attention to quality control than in years past, instruments produced outside the U.S. started shedding their second-class reputation some time ago. In fact, that line has been getting blurrier and blurrier over the past 10–15 years, with some imports being so good as to equal or even rival basses many times their cost in critical areas such as consistency, fretwork, and playability.

A number of basses from many different manufacturers could have fit into this roundup of sub-$1,000 instruments, but for the first of many future roundups we narrowed the field to five basses—three of which are essentially accessibly priced takes on classic, groundbreaking designs from their respective manufacturers. The new G&L Tribute Series M-2000 is modeled after the company’s famous L-Series basses, Fender’s Blacktop Jazz is a souped-up version of their time-tested J bass, and the Sterling by Music Man Ray34CA offers an easier entry into the StingRay arena. We also checked out the classic-looking Ibanez ATK800E Premium and, to make sure we had something for fans of semi-hollowbodies, we took Schecter’s eye-catching Baron-H Vintage for a spin.

Labeling something “moderately priced” is difficult, because it’s certainly varies for every buyer, but each of these basses represents a very solid buy in this price category. Whether you’re an intermediate player who’s recently outgrown your first instrument, a weekend warrior looking for an inspiring new bass, a gigging pro looking for a dependable backup—or even if you’re primarily a guitarist who needs a solid 4-string for home-studio work—this group of quality instruments will satisfy on many, many accounts. And to be able to do all that for under $1,000? Well, that’s pretty grand.


Fender Blacktop Jazz
BY STEVE COOK

Once upon a time, Fender had only one or two bass models in its lineup, starting with the legendary Precision, and then the venerated Jazz. That was about it for the longest time. If you wanted something a little different in your low end, you had to get out your tools and soldering iron and mod it yourself.

Later, with tags such as “entry-level” or “Custom Shop,” different basses (with different price points) were introduced, offering something for almost everyone. In fact, it seems that almost every Fender model has been reborn, reworked, and reissued at some point along the way. The most popular mods that players used to do at home were finally featured in production models, and soon, just about every pickup configuration, neck radius, and color was readily available—but often at a cost that was not insignificant.

Today, whether it’s due to turbulent economic times or a fortuitous combination of creativity and more efficient production costs, many instrument companies have been working overtime to find ways to make quality, affordable instruments with interesting new feature sets. Fender is certainly one of those companies searching for ways to bring fresh ideas to an enticing price point, and one such effort is its new Blacktop series of guitars and basses.

Hot Pavement
The Blacktop series takes familiar Fender body styles and supercharges them with different pickup configurations than we normally see. Specifically, the Precision in the series features dual humbuckers, while the Jazz—the bass reviewed here—is loaded with a pair of split-coil, P-style pickups.

As a whole, the Blacktop Jazz is as familiar as any other. It’s a Mexican-made 4-string with an alder body and a C-shaped maple neck. The glossy finish in white chrome pearl is very sexy, and when paired with the black 3-ply pickguard and classic J-bass knobs, it makes for a great-looking instrument out of the gate. While the factory setup left the action feeling a little high, the neck was even and quick—giving me a first impression of a good overall build.

Lurking just below the strings is the aforementioned anomaly—the two sets of passive, split-coil Precision pickups. For all you DIY- ers out there, Fender did the routing for you! I’ve certainly seen P-bass pickups in J basses, J-bass pickups in P basses, and lots of other variations before, but after hearing all the rumblings in the bass community about this new value line, I was more than curious to see how Fender pulled it off.

Ratings

Pros:
Distinct tones. Good value.

Cons:
Not for the hardcore J- or P-bass purist.

Tones:

Playability/Ease of Use:

Build:

Value:

Street:
$499

Fender
fender.com

Back in Black
For the run-through, I tested the Blacktop Jazz through both a Warwick CCL 210 combo amp and an Eden WT-500 paired with a 115XLT. I figured that putting the bass through its paces with both speaker configurations would give it a fair shake, as some instruments are certainly voiced better for different speakers. As it turned out, the Blacktop Jazz didn’t really care what kind of amp I was using—it told me what it was going to do.

Announcing its presence with authority, the tone from the Blacktop Jazz was big and totally unexpected. I had the control knobs set as high as they could go, and the result was a thick, punchy tone that begged for a hard-rock band. Rolling off the neck pickup really opened the throat of this J and added some low mids and warmth. When I rolled off the bridge pickup slightly, the more familiar Jazz-bass snap came to life. Sonically, the Blacktop Jazz seemed ready to handle a wide range of musical settings, and could be a good low-cost solution in a home or project studio. It’s in that subtle, in-between zone of not exactly a P and not exactly a J, but rather a nice blend of both that can echo tones not usually heard from one or the other.

The Verdict
With its combination of value and tone, the Blacktop Jazz made quite an impression. If you like the body style and thinner neck of a Jazz bass but want more in a pickup than the usual options, then this could be your workhorse. The Blacktop series prides itself on a more powerful stance, and it doesn’t disappoint with this model. Taking a left turn from such successful traditions can often be risky, but Fender hit blacktop with this Jazz.

Watch our video demo:


   1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5    Next »

Related Articles

The Amplifier Wars
FU-Tone.com High Performance Titanium and Brass Bridge Package Reviews
Yamaha BB1025X Bass Guitar Review
Reverend Justice and Thundergun Bass Reviews
All You Need is... Bass!


Comments

(18 comments) display by
UsernameComment
Barry
on 02/25/2013
Nice looking & sounding Bass. I play a G&L JB-2, similar in looks & sound. Differances in the neck.
Richard Hatton
on 02/24/2013
Looking to get a good starter bass, I might have to give this one a try
NOTCHmusic
on 01/04/2013
Exactly Zal S and through the same amp....Impossible to get a reasonable comparison
fhsmct
on 01/03/2013
No mention of the Carvin LB70 series instruments??
fhsmct
on 01/03/2013
ion of the Carvin LB70 series instruments??
Hankster
on 12/18/2012
I ordered the BT Jazz from MF, I tried to like it, put on new regular slinkys, and still found the pickups to sound tinny. I returned that bass and ordered the MIJ '70s P bass, which is less than $1000 and it blows away the BT Jazz IMHO. 2cents
stringbender 53
on 12/14/2012
Hey- you mean someone at Fender finally came up with the idea of putting two P-Bass pups on a Jazz along with a higher mass bridge? I LIKE! The Mexico built Fenders are a great deal for the dough,although the pickups leave a bit to be desired. I could see replacing them with some Seymour's and depending on the colors available adding a White or Black M.O.T.S. pickguard for some flash factor and having a bitchin' working rig.
LowB'Bob
on 12/14/2012
This is one great review!!! I teach bass for free because I want my student to put the money they would norm spend on lessons toward the best bass they can afford. Great demo of finger, slap and pick style. ROCK ON PREMIERGUITARS!!
Ed in Ohio
on 12/14/2012
Very informative and interesting review. Thanks so much for this. Based on its overall write-up and its other category ratings, doesn't the 'value rating' for the Fender Blacktop seem low when one consider it's more than 25% less expensive than the next less expensive bass reviewed here? Would love to hear how you folks would rate the Fender Geddy Lee J-Bass against these. So many say that the Geddy Lee is THE sub-$1,000 benchmark. Thanks again.
Kong
on 12/13/2012
I tried out the 5-string, and it came close to my MuMa SR5, but not too close. The SR 5 has more punch and I like the neck of the SR 5 better. I decidet to get me one for backup in live-situations, because the sound is quite the same. Just roll in a bit more low end for the Sterling By MusicMan, and it works.



Your Comment:  

All comments are subject to editing or deletion by the Premier Guitar staff.

Your Name:  


Please enter the text you see in the image:  
10

61E578C9-FF79-44E4-8E28-A0B932100583