Premier Guitar

Wheels Within Wheels

October 20, 2010
When it comes to comping, we guitarists can learn a lot from B-3 and electric piano players. I’ve always been inspired by how ace keyboardists use inversions and subtle substitutions to create harmonic and rhythmic motion inside the tune’s basic changes. You hear this wheels-within-wheels approach in old-school R&B, blues, and soul-jazz.

For example, imagine a band is vamping on a dominant 7th chord for two measures, marking time until the next chord change. To spur harmonic momentum, a B-3 player might play a series of secondary chords that color the primary dominant 7th chord. Though the essential harmony is static during this two-bar section, we hear chordal movement. What’s going on?

Download Example Audio 1...
Download Example Audio 2...
Download Example Audio 3...

Walk the Line
These secondary voicings are often constructed around a melodic line that’s related to the chord of the moment. One classic line that shows up time and again in groovin’ music from New Orleans funk to Memphis soul derives from boogie-woogie piano and incorporates two chord tones—the 5 and b7—of whatever dominant 7th chord the band is playing at that time, plus the 6, which acts as a stepping stone between the 5 and b7 chord tones. Typically, the line ascends and descends in a 5–6–b7– 6 pattern and is harmonized with several other notes. As we’ll see in a moment, this harmony may be located above or below the 5–6–b7–6 line.

Fig. 1
shows three chord voicings we’ll use to start exploring line-based comping. As you fret these grips, notice how they each occur on the 5th, 4th, and 3rd strings. By staying on these strings, we keep the chords in the guitar’s middle register, an area that grants singers or soloists melodic elbow room.

In Fig. 2, we put these voicings to work to create an A7 comping pattern, which typically occurs over an A pedal tone established by the bassist. Cycle through this phrase several times at a moderate tempo, listening to the harmonic movement and feeling the syncopation in the middle of each measure.

There are several things to consider about this passage. For starters, the 5–6–b7–6 line— which, in this case, is E–F#–G–F#—ascends and descends on the 5th string. Another is that both the A7 and A9 grips are rootless. As long as the root—A—is implied by the bassist or another instrument, you won’t miss it. If you’re flying solo, with no one to pump out a pedal tone below you, you can keep these changes focused within the overarching A7 tonality by simply plucking a low A from time to time.

Unlike its companions, the D chord has a root (it’s located on the 3rd string). But in this context—sandwiched between A7 and A9—the D chord isn’t functioning as a full-on change. Rather, it simply provides momentary tension and release within the comping pattern. This quick, superimposed IV chord is a staple of gospel and blues piano.

One more thing: If you’re into music theory, you’ll notice that our A9 chord is also a first-inversion Em triad, as well as a partial G6. When comping, it’s often the case that you can name a particular cluster of notes several ways, depending on the context. Because we’re comping against an A7, we hear these three notes as a partial A9 chord. In another setting, we might identify them differently.

You can transpose this A7–D–A9–D comping pattern up and down the fretboard. For instance, shift the whole operation up to D7 in the 10th position, and you get a D7–G–D9–G phrase. Start two frets higher in the 12th position and you’ll have an E7–A–E9–A move that sounds great against E7. With a little imagination, you can create a soulful I–IV–V comping pattern to fill out an entire 12-bar blues progression in the key of A. Try it.

Download Example Audio 4...

Download Example Audio 5...
Download Example Audio 6...

Flip It

Next, let’s rework the 5–6–b7–6 line so it becomes the top voice in an A7 comping pattern. Fig. 3 gives you the grips, and Fig. 4 illustrates one of the many ways you can move through them. This particular phrase comes straight out of ’60s organ-driven jazz by the likes of Jimmy Smith, Brother Jack McDuff, Shirley Scott, Lonnie Smith, Jimmy McGriff, and Groove Holmes. As you wrangle this phrase, notice how our E–F#–G–F# line now ascends and descends on the 3rd string. If you have a Leslie simulator or a Uni-Vibe pedal, by all means kick it on.

Mix and Match

So far, we’ve placed the 5–6–b7–6 line in either the lowest voice or highest voice of our comping patterns. But you can mix the two approaches, as shown in Fig. 5. Here, the 5–6 (E–F#) portion ascends on the 3rd string, while the b7–6 section (G–F#) descends on the 5th string. It’s a cool sound.

All Together Now
These comping patterns really come alive when you weave them into a longer progression. In Fig. 6—which sounds especially sweet played with a relaxed swing feel—we apply our new moves to a V–IV–I sequence in the key of A. By playing a voicing on virtually every beat, you generate momentum and harmonic complexity without obscuring the underlying cadence: E7 (bar 1), D7 (bar 2), and A7 (bars 3 and 4). Try dropping this sequence into the last four bars of a 12-bar blues or shuffle in the key of A.

Next month, we’ll explore more ways to build comping patterns around lines. In the meantime, work out these moves in other keys and then look for ways to use them in your next jam or recording session.


Comping. The word “comp” is jazzbo slang for “accompany,” as in, “I’ll comp while you take a solo.” Comping also implies playing a chord progression with some rhythmic variation.

Scale and Chord Formulas. You’ll often see a scale, chord, or phrase expressed numerically, such as the 5–6–b7–6 line discussed in this lesson. These numerical formulas are derived from a major scale—our musical yardstick—and come in handy when you want to describe an item’s musical construction, independent of any key. Every chord type or scale type has a formula, and once you know it, you can apply it to any major scale to generate the notes for the given chord, phrase, or scale in that key.

For example, the formula for a minor 7th chord is 1–b3–5–b7 . To identify the notes in, say, Cm7, simply apply its formula to the parallel major scale— i.e., the major scale that shares the same root. In this case, that’s a C major scale (C–D–E–F–G–A–B), so applying the minor 7th formula yields C–Eb–Bb–G, Cm7’s chord tones.

Pedal Tones.
A pedal tone (or pedal point) is a note that sustains against a passage, acting as a tonal anchor. A pedal tone is usually played in the bass register below the musical activity, but can also ride above it, as in a blues turnaround when the highest note remains static while other intervals ascend or descend against it.

Andy Ellis

PG Senior Editor Andy Ellis is a veteran guitar journalist. Since cutting his teeth on British Invasion bands—the Who, Yardbirds, and Pretty Things got the party started—he has been a certified guitar nut. Now based in Nashville, Andy backs singer-songwriters on the baritone guitar. He also hosts a weekly radio program, The Guitar Show, that broadcasts on-air and online. For the broadcast schedule, links to the stations’ streams, archived audio interviews with inspiring players, and more, visit