August 2008

Story Tools
   Email This Article
   Print This Article
   Add Your Comments
   Subscribe Now!


Rate This Article
Low   High
Current rating: 5 stars by 2 users

Most Popular Articles
   Dimebag's Dean of Destiny
   Review: Fractal Audio Axe-FX
   Berkley Rock City
   Review: Gretsch "Double Annie"
   Building an Esquire for Under a Grand

Highest Rated Articles
   The Acoustic Arts
   Theo Hartman: Mojo Agnostic
   Magnum Opus J-6250WC Jumbo Cutaway
   Dream Shredding with Michael Angelo Batio
   Dimebag's Dean of Destiny

    
August 2008 \ Web Exclusives \ Product Review \ Review: The Tone God TubeUlent Amp/Preamp

Review: The Tone God TubeUlent Amp/Preamp

by Bob Goffstein

Small, real-deal tube amp offers solid tone that's portable and versatile



Imagine an amp that's closer to pedal-size than a full-size amp, but is actually a genuine tube amp with tones ranging from meaty growls to sparkling clarity. Designed to be controlled like a preamp, it would allow you to plug into anything. Now throw in a head-turning, rugged design with LEDs and visible tubes -- you've got a portable tone monster that every guitarist in the room will be asking you about during the break.


The TubeUlent preamp manufactured by The Tone God (TTG) came with a note from the manufacturer, Andrew, that closed with the salutation, “enjoy”. Enjoy is exactly what I have been doing for the past few weeks as I checked out this snazzy little unit and its capabilities.

The first exciting thing about this unit is, believe it or not, its appearance. It has a black cast metal housing that measures 5.7” wide by 3.6” deep by 1.9” tall. There are 5 nicely knurled metal knobs, a 1/4" input jack and a small pilot light on the front. There's a 1/4” output jack and power supply input on the back and four 3/8” tall hard plastic feet on the bottom. The top of the unit is where things get interesting . There is an on/off toggle switch, a small nine-pin preamp tube socket, and a larger 8 pin power tube socket. There unit ships with a 12AX7 preamp tube and 6V6 power tube. There are 2 slabs of 1/2” thick clear acrylic measuring 5.1” long by 3.25 tall standing upright in front of and behind the tube section. These are secured by machine screws at their bases and braced by steel tubing spacers separating the two slabs at the top.

A really cool touch - LEDs are embedded in the base of each acrylic “window” that illuminate the lettering etched into the plastic. Besides providing the name of the unit and the manufacturer it also identifies each jack and knob, making set up and use of the unit very straight forward. The effect is startling. Think Ampeg B-15 Portaflex amp section with more attitude.

There are five knobs. The easily understood “drive,” “EQ,” and “level” knobs are similar to those found on almost all overdrive type effects units. The other two knobs, labeled “damp” and “sag” require some knowledge of tube amp theory to understand and there is a very good discussion of their function on the website; more details and theory may be found in Aspen Pittman’s classic book on tube amp design.

Basically, they both give the amp a “tighter” or “looser” feel. Their function is usually one ascribed to the power output section of a tube amp but in this case the sonic characteristics are generated in what would have to be described as a preamp unit. It is these functions (among other things) that separate this unit from the rest of the pack.

Free-standing tube overdrive/preamp units are not a new species in the guitar biosphere. It all started with B.K. Butler’s “Real Tube,” of which I still have both the pedal version and the rack mount studio version, and there have been many fine units to come along in the mean time.

The TubeUlent appears to be a very well-built, robust unit. I was unable to access the inside of the unit due to the fact that the bottom access panel is glued to the rest of the enclosure. There is a strict warning about not trying to open the unit because of “lethal voltages” inside. That seems a little unusual because the unit is powered by a separate power supply generating 15 volts, a la your laptop computer. However, anytime you're converting low adapter voltage to higher tube voltage, being overly cautious isn't a bad idea.

While some may consider an external power supply a liability, I personally found it to be a major asset, especially in the recording studio, where it was able to keep background noise to a bare minimum in the face of high gain levels. Using a cable with a unipoint ground shield also helps combat noise.

Another of the unusual features of this unit is the use of a power output tube (6V6) as a secondary gain stage. We tend to think of preamp tubes as small, warm, low voltage devices and power tubes as somewhat larger, high voltage devices that get hot. If we think not of tubes but of “valves” as the British call them, we are more likely to realize they are multipotent devices consisting of filaments, plates, and grids that can be used in many ways. Although I had no access to the circuitry, the fact that the 6V6 remains merely warm to the touch suggests that it is being used in a non-standard way to provide output signal voltage.

The Tone God confirmed my suspicion. Here's his response: "The tubes do run cooler because the filaments are run at 6 volts instead of 6.3, still well within the voltage range to cause conduction in the cathode. This is done to generate less heat, a major enemy of electronics, and extends the life of the tube's filament drastically and thus the life of the tube. All the tubes are running at high voltage."

A couple of other cool features are a pilot light that flashes at startup to indicate status of the circuits and a tube retainer floating above the 6V6 that doesn’t actually touch it but sort of provides a halo over this little tone god’s head.

I started testing by listening to the unit with headphones. On its highest output setting it has enough signal to power relatively efficient headphones such as the ever-popular Sony MDR-7506s. This also showed me that the output level pot has an unusual taper in which the last 20-30 degrees of clockwise travel contained the greatest amount of added gain; ie. a reverse audio taper.

The unit was very smooth with the seductive sound (at least to us old tube guys) of sweet harmonic distortion. The gain control did its job with authority, taking the sonic journey from clean to moderately high gain overdrive with the same basic tonality. The EQ control provided high freq cut while preserving mids and lows. The “damp” control worked seamlessly to provide a tighter (Fender SF, Hiwatt) sound to a looser “tweed” or Valco feel. The “sag” knob did basically the same thing, but with less authority as the damp control but also added a slight volume prefade at the initiation of each note; a passable facsimile of true power supply/rectifier sag.

Next, I picked a couple of my amps that had effects loops and plugged the TubeUlent into the return jack. To put it succinctly, it sounded awesome with both humbuckers and single coils. One mild concern was that on full gain settings the humbuckers lost a bit of bite even on full “treble” and yielded a beautiful “woman tone” gain. The single coils had enough inherent highs for this not to be a concern. The Boogie studio 22 has a graphic equalizer on the output section so I was able to coax as much bite, or picking attack as anyone might want out of it. The Fender Hot Rod Deluxe has a presence control on the output amp that also ramped up the highs.

The next step was to plug directly in to a Yamaha powered PA line input. I was more than pleased at the tube tone emanating from the solid state amp into a Carvin PA speaker. The effects and EQ did a good imitation of a good tube amp unless one added too many highs, at which point the solid state sound poked though. One could easily gig without an amp by using this setup as long as there are individual monitor feeds for each player.

The obvious question then popped into my head. How will this preamp sound if we use it just as a distortion/gain effect in front of a guitar amp’s input? Here's my answer: transparently beautiful on every amp I used including: A Clark Beaufort 2x10, an Ampeg mid 60s Reverberocket, the previously mentioned Fender HR Deluxe and Boogie, and my Old Flame from Allen Amps. I added some effect boxes both pre and post and the TubeUlent handled it all.

I then waltzed my little darlin’ into my project studio and recorded it both straight and with all manner of effects, both floor boxes and plug-ins. It really sounded sweet through the Avalon 737 with a bit of compression and EQ.

Lastly, but not leastly, I fired up the TubeUlent with some other preamp tubes, a 12AT7 and a 12AU7. The 12AX7 has an amplification factor of 100; the 12AT7 has one of 70; and the 12AU7 has a factor of 40. As expected, the AT7 affected the final amount of overdrive available, but also seemed to decrease the highs a slight bit. The AU7 decreased the amount of available gain significantly and also decreased highs. As the amount of overdrive decreases, the increment of adjustment increases, making it easier to fine tune the gain especially on high signal level input devices such as harp mics.

Our harp player tried the unit out and was very excited about it and believe me, he is very fussy about his tone.

As you can tell, I really like this unit. One nit-picky concern for me is the unit's hard plastic feet. When it comes to keeping things from sliding around I have better luck with rubber feet. On the other side of the coin - the unit's hard plastic feet will no doubt last longer. They even have molded-in metal washers to keep them from getting torn off. The feet are also high enough to clear the rubber handles of many common amps but low enough to rest against the rubber handle mounts. Other thoughts - I think the unit looks so cool I could envision the company devising a way to mount it on a stand to bring it into view before its adoring public. Also, being such a versatile tool for tone hounds, I wouldn't mind having more than one EQ control.

Overall, the TubeUlent is a great sounding amp that will open you up to new possibilities with your sound and your rig. I hesitate to call this the “Swiss Army Knife” of input devices, especially since it is made in Canada, but the temptation is there.

buy if

You are a guitar or harp player that likes to experiment with tone; especially if you are into recording
skip if

Your solid state amp sounds "just fine"
rating...
5.0
MSRP $599 - The Tone God - thetonegod.com







Commentary

UsernameComment
1 2 3 
Pepto Floyd
on 08/19/2008
Davie Allan's music from his Fender Jazzmaster is like stopping at a truck stop and it looks like a normal hot dog until you bite into it. Then there's a rumbling down inside that causes a gusher to explode forth and with sudden vicious velocity!Chunks and splatters of debris come flying out and no amount of air freshener can clear the atmosphere of the loudness that has transpired.This may be a crude example but it's not your daddy's surf music Jazzmaster. It's from the dark alley and painted black as girls walk by in their summer clothes. Fender is afraid to put that thing out!
The Tone God, Andrew
on 08/05/2008
Thanks! I always enjoy talking gear. The switchable power tube type was on the wish list along with a few other things but we just ran out of time. We had to get a product out the door and start establishing ourselves. BTW I do like some of the small amps. Particularly the ones that are prone to modding but thats the tech in me. Can't leave well enough alone.
Tone Hound
on 07/31/2008
Of course a single tube/ended amp needs no biasing, ever. Instead of using a 6V6 in the Tubulent, why not use a tube in the 6L6, EL34 family. That would allow many more power tube options for the user to try. I also think that there is more to tube rectifiers than just superstition. Finally (and I mean it) many of the new small tube amps that are out there now have a lot of tonal options. Check 'em out for ideas! Thanks Andrew for being a sport and fielding these comments! You're very knowledgeable.
The Tone God, Andrew
on 07/31/2008
We are still working on our dealer chain and can't say what they will sell them for. It will be up to them. We are planning on opening an online store so you can buy direct from us. We haven't set the price but it will be below MSRP.
middle earth
on 07/31/2008
what does this thing street for. Why is this one of the last industries on earth that still bandied MSRP's around?
The Tone God, Andrew
on 07/31/2008
Most amps will eventually need work like cap replacement. The TubeUlent does not. And no the TubeUlent does not need biasing ever. I don't know why having a good range on the sag is bad thing. This is one of the most important aspects of an amp's behaviour IMHO. Here you can adjust the amount to exactly what you like. Why do some amp companies still use tube rectifiers ? Many reasons including economics and engineering but a huge factor is marketing. Musicians are very superstitious about gear. Rectifier tubes play into this perception hence this conversation we are having. Truth be told any decent amp designer can design an amp to behave exactly like an amp with a tube rectifier but then there is an uphill battle to convince superstitious musicians that it works...much like convincing people that a little preamp box can sound like an amp. ;) The triode/pentode switch...honestly never thought about it. The price quoted is MSRP not street.
Tone Hound
on 07/31/2008
Most decent tube amps are pretty low maintenance. As with your product, it's mostly the tubes that need occasional replacement and in some cases, rebiasing may be necessary depending on the circuit design. Yes, I am thinking of plate voltage starved circuits. Don't like those. It's a known fact that running the heaters at a lower voltage will reduce heat in ALL tubes. If you're trying to emulate a tube amp, extreme adjustment of power supply sag would be missing the point. As I said, there is nothing wrong with a solid state rectifier but you may also want to consider that most highly regarded "boutique" amps use a tube rectifier. Why? Also, you can't really refer to Tubulent as an amp as is implied in the review. It's more of a preamp if you ask me. In order to play through the mighty Tubulent, you still need some sort of amplifier thingy that will drive a speaker. As I said, 600 clams is 600 clams and there's no way you can convince me that a wall-wart power supply, a couple of tubes, a tiny chasis and a few pots and switches is worth those 600 bucks or even 400 bucks. I'm just stating my opinion because that's what this space is for. Calling yourself "The Tone God" is blasphemy in my book! I wish you the best of luck! By the way, what about the triode/pentode suggestion? Why is that a bad idea?
The Tone God, Andrew
on 07/31/2008
A rectifier tube gets hotter then even power tubes. It would require another power supply section for the 5V heater that supplies alot of current. The extra space needed for the tube would make the unit larger. It creates another point of failure. Finally the rectifier is used with AC where the TubeUlent is all DC to keep noise down. All this adds to increased size, weight, cost, labour, reliability, and noise potential. Yes recitifer sag can be made somewhat adjustable but only to a limited degree before you affect the gain structure of the whole amp including the preamp. The TubeUlent does not suffer from this problem and gives you more range in the end. There is no advantage to using a tube recitifer. There is no advantage to having a power transformer. To add an output transformer would have required a custom transformer adding to the weight, size, and cost of the unit yet again. There is a misunderstand to what the "low voltage" part of the review refers to. The filaments are running at a slightly lower voltage. This does NOT affect the sound at all. You maybe thinking of plate voltage starved circuits in which case the review points out that the tubes are running at high voltage so there is no issue there. Comparing a preamp to an amp does not make sense. You can buy a small amp but then you are locking into one amp's behaviour. With the TubeUlent you can adjust the response and choose what volume level to run at without the extra gear. Finally something that the TubeUlent does that does not get great praise for except when it is needed is the self protection circuitry. With an amp if you something goes wrong it generally means a trip to the tech. The TubeUlent protects itself from several different bad situations saving you money. A tube amp needs regular maintenance. The TubeUlent, other then the tubes themselves, does not need maintenance. Once again different tools for different jobs.
Tone Hound
on 07/31/2008
While I'm at it, I may as well admit that tubes running at low voltage do not get as hot. OK. They also don't sound as good from my experience. I have a Vox Tonelab LE. It's rated as being a better sounding tube amp emulation. Yet, I'm rather disappointed in the sound it produces. If you want great tube tone, buy a small tube amp. It's the real deal!
Tone Hound
on 07/31/2008
I forgot to mention a few things in my last post. First, I am aware that all of the small tube amps I recommended have solid state rectifiers. These amps are also much more affordable and flexible. For the price of the TUBULENT, you could buy a small tube amp and a decent mic to record it with and still have money left over for a pizza!



Your Comment:  

All comments are subject to editing or deletion by the Premier Guitar staff.

Your Name:  


Please enter the text you see in the image:  

     Get your own Subscription to PG Today!


Link to this Article

Want to link to this article? Just copy and paste the text below into your website.
F4676528-0E0E-4889-A9A5-BC0627C9C445 1702