Premier Guitar features affiliate links to help support our content. We may earn a commission on any affiliated purchases.

Evaluating Your Guitar, Part 2

Unpacking the Value of "Limited" and Signed Guitars

You’ve hung in this far – only one more installment to go and we’ll get back to our normal Trash or Treasure articles. Last month, I really dove into the meat and potatoes of guitar evaluation, and I’m going to finish it up with some tangents and a conclusion.

Limited Editions
This is a phrase so many of us like to hear because it makes the guitar in question sound special. What is a limited edition? The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition defines it as “An edition, as of a book or print, that is restricted to a limited number of copies.” That sounds simple enough, but what does it mean when it is applied to guitars?

Let’s say Joe Buck Guitars built 1,000 instruments, finished 750 in standard colors, 250 in custom colors, and called the smaller batch limited editions. Would you pay more for a guitar that is exactly the same but has a limited edition finish? Gibson is notorious for this, and it confuses many people into thinking they have a Custom Shop model when it is nothing more than a standard production guitar with a special finish. In order for a limited edition guitar to be worth a premium, it has to have some real collector appeal or other special feature.

Zach Fjestad shown defacing Crafter guitar – guaranteed to double the value!
Remember the scene in Half Baked when Jim Breuer’s character Brian is at work at the record store. He offers a customer $5 for a used Kenny Loggins record, when the customer, obviously offended, reminds him that Kenny Loggins himself has signed it. Brian replies, “Alright, I’ll give you $4.” I’ve appraised several guitars and when they’re signed, most people think they have a nine-pound piece of solid gold, shaped like a guitar. 99.9% of the time, the only value attached to the signature is the nostalgia the owner has to the person who signed it. When originality dictates how much collectors will pay for a certain guitar, a signature may actually take away from the value of the instrument! If you had an original ’59 Burst, would you have anybody sign it, even if it was Ted McCarty himself? Don’t get me wrong, a signed guitar can be cool, but don’t expect the guitar to be worth more because of the signature.

Originality and Authenticity
These are words all guitar collectors need to take seriously. When it comes to value, originality is almost as important as condition. Look for replaced parts, repairs and refinishes on guitars. A refinished guitar is typically worth only 50% of an original finish. Sometimes if a person refinishes a 60% guitar it becomes worth less because the 60% price is higher than half the 98% mint price. There are a lot of nonethical builders that are trying to cash in on the vintage guitar boom by producing excellent copies and fakes. Some copies are really good, and people have been fooled into shelling out too much cash for a ’59 ‘Burst that they believe is authentic, but in reality was a fake built in Japan! Make sure you inspect a guitar from endto- end to ensure authenticity – otherwise you may find yourself taking an unwanted bath.

Trash or Treasure
Hopefully you’ve learned something over the past couple of issues when it comes to identifying, dating, and evaluating your guitar. However, if I give you too much information, guitar owners will be able to do all of this on their own and I’ll be out of a job! There are only a few things you really need to know to determine “Trash or Treasure.” Identify the proper manufacturer and model, date the guitar, and use the tools I provided to evaluate it. Next month, it is back to individual models and I encourage readers to send in guitars that you are curious about – you never know what I may dig up!

Zachary R. Fjestad
Zachary R. Fjestad is the author of the Blue Book of Acoustic Guitars, Blue Book of Electric Guitars, and the Blue Book of Guitar Amplifiers.

Guitar Trash or Treasure Questions can be submitted to:
Blue Book Publications
Attn: Guitar Trash or Treasure
8009 34th Ave. S. Ste #175
Minneapolis, MN 55425
Please include pictures of your guitars.

On her new record with her trio, Molly Miller executes a live-feeling work of structural harmony that mirrors her busy life.

Photo by Anna Azarov

The accomplished guitarist and teacher’s new record, like her lifestyle, is taut and exciting—no more, and certainly no less, than is needed.

Molly Miller, a self-described “high-energy person,” is fully charged by the crack of dawn. When Ischeduled our interview, she opted for the very first slot available—8:30 a.m.—just before her 10 a.m. tennis match!

Read MoreShow less

John Mayall in the late ’80s, in a promo shot for his Island Records years. During his carreer, he also recorded for the Decca (with the early Bluesbreakers lineups), Polydor, ABC, DJM, Silvertone, Eagle, and Forty Below labels.

He was dubbed “the father of British blues,” but Mayall’s influence was worldwide, and he nurtured some of the finest guitarists in the genre, including Eric Clapton, Peter Green, Mick Taylor, Harvey Mandel, Coco Montoya, and Walter Trout. Mayall died at his California home on Monday, at age 90.

John Mayall’s career spanned nearly 70 years, but it only took his first four albums to cement his legendary status. With his initial releases with his band the Bluesbreakers—1966’s Blues Breakers with Eric Clapton; ’67’s A Hard Road, with Peter Green on guitar; plus the same year’s Crusade, which showcased Mick Taylor—and his solo debut The Blues Alone, also from 1967, Mayall introduced an international audience of young white fans to the decidedly Black and decidedly American genre called blues. In the subsequent decades, he maintained an active touring and recording schedule until March 26, 2022, when he played his last gig at age 87. It was reported that he died peacefully, on Monday, in his California home, at 90.

Read MoreShow less

Featuring enhanced amp models, a built-in creative looper, AI-powered tone exploration, and smart jam features.

Read MoreShow less

Donner andThird Man Hardware’s $99, three-in-one analog distortion, phaser, and delay honors Jack White’s budget gear roots.

Compact. Light. Fun. Dirt cheap. Many cool sounds that make this pedal a viable option for traveling pros.

Phaser level control not much use below 1 o’clock. Repeats are bright for an analog delay. Greater range of low-gain sounds would be nice.


Donner X Third Man Triple Threat


A huge part of the early White Stripes mystique, sound, ethos, and identity was tied to guitars and amps that, at the time, you could luck into for cheap at a garage sale. These days, it’s harder to score a Crestwood Astral II, or Silvertone Twin Twelve with a part-time job in the ice cream shop. Back in the late ’90s, though, they were a source of raw, nasty sounds for less than a new, more generic guitar or amp.

Read MoreShow less