Affordability is no obstacle to top quality in this understated P/J-style bass.
Solid construction. Beautiful finish. Affordable price.
Overly bright onboard electronics. No passive operation. No option to switch batteries quickly.
$549
ESP LTD AP-204
espguitars.com
Famed Japanese brand ESP launched the LTD series in 1996 as an affordable line aimed at the beginner market. But a visit to the LTD website these days reveals a line evolved well beyond that original premise, with a wide variety of offerings in several price ranges.
Stylistically speaking, brand associations can be a funny thing. I always associated the LTD series with metal and related aesthetics. But the AP-204 represents a much more understated and middle-of-the-road approach with P-Bass-meets-Music Man style and an active P/J pickup setup. The $549 price is a bit higher than some Indonesia-built instruments from competing brands, but the AP-204 delivers a lot of sounds and excellent quality for the price.
Solid as a Rock
The LTD is a well-built bass. As a player who performs live a lot and sometimes bends a neck for a little vibrato or whammy effect (not a practice I recommended, by the way), I'm reassured by an instrument that feels solid and battle-ready. Casual inspection makes it easy to explain the solid feel of the instrument. The neck/body joint is tight, with no visible gap, and the bolt-on neck is affixed with six screws instead of four—a construction technique more commonly seen on higher-priced instruments. The fret ends are nicely rounded and the satin finish on the back of the J-Bass-sized neck is exceptionally comfortable. The test bass also arrived with a perfect setup that required no tweaking before I tested it—not a common occurrence. The pièce de résistance might be the gorgeous metallic purple finish that looks dark and unassuming under normal lighting, but takes on a much more flamboyant personality under bright lights.
The Modern Edge
The bass features straightforward volume and blend controls, and a bass/treble stacked EQ setup. And when playing the AP-204 straight into my user interface and computer, I had to cut the treble about 70 percent to get the sound I associate most with a P/J-bass—not entirely vintage, but not inflexibly modern. Even with that much treble cut, the LTD provided great sustain and a tone with solid lows, musical mids, and present highs that could work for many applications without much processing. This is a great starting point for any instrument, regardless of price.
The sound of my finger pops were quite a lot brighter than I anticipated—with shades of a modern MTD-on-a-budget tone.
Of course, the beauty of any P/J-bass is the ability to use the P-style pickup by itself, and on that count the LTD does not disappoint. With a little tone attenuation, the bass provides plenty of traditional P-style honk and woodiness. Fingerstyle moves in this configuration never sounded muddy or without character. After this encouraging experiment, I returned the bass to a 50/50 pickup blend and rolled the treble back up to check how it reacted to slap technique. Instantly the sound of my finger pops were quite a lot brighter than I anticipated—with shades of a modern MTD-on-a-budget tone. And while the jatoba fretboard is ostensibly a stand-in for rosewood, it seemed to lend more of a bright maple tonality in slapping situations. Palm-muted picking, meanwhile, revealed a cool low-mid thump that some similar instruments easily lose when played with a pick. And a quick recording of this approach demonstrated that this bass sits just about perfectly in this context without taking up too much sonic space.
The Verdict
Just a little time with the LTD AP-204 makes it clear what a solid, all-around bass it is—although there is room for small improvements. Because the bass does not have a passive/active switch, I would switch the battery door from a 2-screw setup to a flip-open compartment to facilitate quick battery changes. It could also benefit from a slightly less bright EQ circuit and a little more range for high-end cut. But unless you are a strictly vintage-oriented player, this might not be an issue for you. More than anything, I am impressed with the build, quality control, and finish on this LTD, which makes me more than a little curious about other offerings from the line. This AP-204 is clearly capable of delivering more than metal tones—and offers great value.
Wireless technology is thriving in all parts of the techno-sphere and it's time for bassists to catch up.
What were the most dangerous times for bassists, guitarists, and singers? Surely the '60s. Not because of wild backstage parties, drug abuse, or high-risk early international travel, but simply because of electrocution caused by amateurish electrical installations with missing grounds.
That's exactly what inspired Leo Fender to develop the TR-105, the first "Wireless Remote Unit," as they called it, back in 1961. Unlike the P-bass, this was really a world's first, but unfortunately a rather unsuccessful one. The unit was directed at guitarists, bassists, and accordionists, and had a radius of 50 feet—enough distance for those pre-arena stage dimensions. It looked surprisingly similar to modern units: a set-top box and a belt pack. Its transmitter, which weighed only 5 ounces, had an impressive frequency range of 20 Hz–75 kHz, while the receiver covered 20 Hz–20 kHz, with 100 to 150 hours of operation on one mercury battery. The system came with a hardcase, weighed 15 pounds, and cost $269.50—roughly $2,500 today. For whatever reason, it didn't catch on and Fender only offered it for around a year.
It wasn't until 1976 that Nasty Cordless, Inc. (later renamed Nady Systems) and Ken Schaeffer's Vega Diversity successfully entered a broader market. Both were analog devices and used a process called companding: a word-mix of compression at the sender side and expansion on the receiver side.
The specialty of the Vega was an integrated audio circuit that was known to colorize tone. This doesn't have to be a bad thing, as AC/DC's Angus Young is still using his today, even in the studio, and sees it as a central device for his signature sound. (See PG's AC/DC Rig Rundown from September 2016.) These systems also had greater operation ranges, so they were good for stadium stages.
Today, wireless technology is thriving in all aspects of electronic products, with cables nearly a thing of the past, except among—astonishingly—many musicians who still like to knot and tangle them.
Wireless systems got a bad reputation because of their early teething troubles, which included dropouts and problems picking up radio transmissions. Some guitarists really look down on them because of these initial foibles. Today's budget analog wireless systems can have companders with a fixed ratio, and this can make them sound unnatural. Better ones have more natural sounding companders that make it much harder to tell the difference between wired and wireless sounds. And the newer digital systems are even topping these, with their high-quality A/D converters.
In the foreground of today's discussions about wireless systems are most often things like tone, dynamics, range, energy consumption, bandwidth, and dropouts, while electrocution isn't that much of an issue. Although it should be for anyone touring exotic places with lesser-controlled electrical environments.
Today, wireless technology is thriving in all aspects of electronic products, with cables nearly a thing of the past, except among—astonishingly—many musicians who still like to knot and tangle them. As with all things mechanical, cable breakage isn't such a rarity and one might even be tempted to say that newer wireless devices excel in reliability. And—opposed to many early transmitters—they've switched to USB-equipped accumulators and far lower energy consumption. Choosing a system is almost a no-brainer, even though the sheer number of models is vast. With the exception of low-end budget models, almost all units fulfill the criteria of reliability, tone, ease of use, and operational range.
Fender was first in the wireless game with its unsuccessful TR-105 in 1961.
For us bassists, there are a few extra points to keep in mind. Our signal is pretty dynamic, so our wireless system should be as well. Analog wireless systems need to compress the dynamic range of the audio before it can be carried on a radio wave. Not only can this have an impact on tone; it also limits dynamics. Therefore, digital is the way to go, especially since these have a better low-end range.
All those owning basses with active pickups or preamps should check compatibility before buying, plus keep a few other things in mind. It's sometimes not mentioned in a system's spec lists whether it will work with an active instrument's stereo output jacks, due to a TRS-related connection issue that can occur. Output levels of active pickups can be another issue, which is why many devices come with a gain-adjustment at the transmitter. And finally, there can be whining and noise caused by insufficient shielding of the preamp on your bass, once the transmitter is plugged in and close to the electronics housing. To solve that, just look for a cable-equipped belt pack to keep the receiver's antennas farther away from it.
Some other common features to look for are capacity-load cable simulations, which are more directed at guitarists, and durable metal body packs, for the touring artist. Multiple transmitter supports could be nice to have, but are not essential.
Some research will help you find the right system. Don't be afraid to cut the cable! You might enjoy your new freedom to roam the stage.
Bold, minimalist style meets multitudinous tones.
Solid build. Great onboard active EQ. Ultra-comfortable neck. Rock star looks.
A passive tone control would be nice. Limited paint options
$949
Charvel Pro-Mod San Dimas PJ IV
charvel.com
For a large part of the guitar-playing population, seeing "Charvel" on a headstock inevitably leads to thoughts of over-the-top paint jobs and Floyd Rose tremolos. And while Charvel built great instruments for use outside the shred realm, traditionally shaped bass guitars are probably not the first thing you associate with the brand.
Prior to this review, my only impression of Charvel as a bass builder was hearing about Lee Sklar going to the Charvel shop in the '70s to pick out the body for his legendary P-style bass—the instrument that eventually became "one of the most recorded basses in history" in his own estimation. That's not an inconsequential bass legacy. And the Pro-Mod San Dimas PJ IV certainly feels like it's built from that substantial foundation.
A Lot of Flash With a Little Bit of Cream
Charvel began as a high-end repair and custom shop in Los Angeles. During its '80s heyday, the brand was owned by Jackson. But since 2002 Charvel has been part of the Fender family, and the visual influence of the parent company shows through here.
The first thing that struck me about the Pro-Mod San Dimas was an immediate feeling of deep affection for the vintage DiMarzio cream pickup covers—a classy statement on any instrument no matter the paint scheme that transports me to the time I first picked up a bass. The second thing I thought was, "Holy smokes, this bass is very green!!" (In addition to the lime green metallic finish on our review model, the 4-string version also comes in a more sedate mystic blue).
The roasted maple that makes up the neck, 12"-16" compound-radius fretboard, and headstock give this traditionally shaped bass a unique, understated look that's a nice contrast to the bold green finish.
Precision Re-imagination
You can make a lot of sounds with any good P/J setup. But you can cover a lot of extra mileage with what this race car has under the hood. The San Dimas PJ IV features DiMarzio Model J DP123 and Model P DP122 pickups in the bridge and neck respectively, a 3-band active treble/mid/bass boost/cut tone control array equipped with a push/pull switch for passive operation, as well as pickup balance and master volume controls. The slim C-neck is graphite reinforced, features convenient heel access to the truss rod adjustment wheel, and has very nice rolled edges, which makes the neck feel even slimmer. Luminous fretboard side dots are a suitably flashy but practical finishing touch.
The Charvel communicates quite a bit more midrange information than most other P/J setups.
Simple Lines, Multiple Tones
The best, simplest way to describe the Pro-Mod's sound with both pickups all the way up and the active tone stack engaged is full. There's a distinctive piano-like zing in the high end and a very firm, solid low end that doesn't come across as too modern or too stiff. The output is impressively even across the neck and in all registers. One reason for the balanced output is the reverse-P pickup (with the bass segment of the split pickup shifted closer to the bridge). The setup helps the first and second strings ring with authority and lends a very strong low-end presence. The overall voice of the instrument is distinctly P/J, but with some of a Spector's extra punchy top and low end on tap. The bass also feelsincredibly solid. The high mass bridge adds sustain and helps create a sense of playing a neck-thru instrument when bending or playing aggressively.
Coaxing a more vintage-style voice out of this speed racer is as easy as engaging the passive circuit and grabbing a pick. A slightly softer voice emerges, but it's filled with personality. Playing with a pick in passive configuration also reveals that the Charvel communicates quite a bit more midrange information than most other P/J setups. Although the midrange overall is strong, it's easy to use the active EQ to scoop some out, but there is no tone control in passive operation. However, in this mode the Charvel rewarded me with a hot-rodded J-bass-style slap tone that's a great addition to any bassist's bag of tricks and well-suited to the slim, fast neck.
The Verdict
For some, the look of the Charvel Pro-Mod San Dimas PJ IV will be enough to evoke stereotypical associations with hair spray and the Sunset Strip circa '86. But this bass is much more than a flashy finish. It's one of the most well-built and versatile examples I have played in a very long time. All the Pro-Mod features are player-oriented additions that make sense rather than feeling like sales gimmicks. At less than a thousand bucks, the Pro-Mod San Dimas PJ IV provides pro-level playability, quality feel, and a tone palette that you typically hear from instruments priced two or three times higher.