Three thrilling variations on the ā60s-fuzz theme.
Three very distinct and practical voices. Searing but clear maximum-gain tones. Beautiful but practically sized.
Less sensitive to volume attenuation than some germanium fuzz circuits.
$199
Warm Audio Warm Bender
warmaudio.com
In his excellent videoFuzz Detective, my former Premier Guitar colleague and pedal designer Joe Gore put forth the proposition that theSola Sound Tone Bender MkII marked the birth of metal. TakeWarm Audioās Warm Bender for a spin and itās easy to hear what he means. Itās nasty and itās heavyāelectrically awake with the high-mid buzz you associate with mid-ā60s psych-punk, but supported with bottom-end ballast that can knock you flat (which may be where the metal bit comes in).
The Warm Bender dishes these sounds with ease and savage aplomb. Outwardly, it honors the original MkIIāa good way to go given that the original Sola Sound unit is one the most stylish effects ever built. But the 3-transistor NOS 75 MkII is only one of the Warm Benderās personalities. You can also switch to a 2-transistor NOS 76 circuit, aka the Tone Bender MkI. Thereās also a silicon 3-transistor Tone Bender circuit, a twist explored by several modern boutique builders. Each of these three voices can be altered further by the crown-mounted sag switch, which starves the circuit of voltage, reducing power from 9 to 6 volts. From these three circuits, the Warm Bender conjures voices that are smooth, responsive, ragged, mean, mangled, clear, and positively fried.
The Compact Wedge Edge
Warm Audio, quite wisely, did not put the Warm Bender in an authentically, full-size Tone Bender enclosure, which would gobble a lot of floor space. But this smaller, approximately 2/3-scale version, complete with a Hammerite finish, looks nearly as hip. Itās sturdy, too. The footswitch and jacks are affixed directly to the substantial enclosure entirely apart from the independently mounted through-hole circuit board, which, for containing three circuits rather than one, is larger and more densely populated than the matchbox-sized circuit boards in a ā60s Tone Bender. Despite the more cramped quarters, thereās still room for a 9V battery if you choose to run it that way. Topside, thereās not much to the Warm Bender. Thereās a chicken-head knob for output volume, another for gain, and a third that switches between the NOS 76, NOS 75, and silicon modes. Even the most boneheaded punk could figure this thing out.
A Fuzz Epic in Three Parts
Most Warm Bender customers will find their way to the pedal via MkII lust. If you arrive here by that route you wonāt be disappointed. The Warm Benderās NOS 75 setting delivers all the glam-y, proto-metal, heavy filth you could ask for. It sounded every bit as satisfying as my own favorite MkII clone save for a hint of extra compression that falls well within the bounds of normal vintage fuzz variation. My guess is that when youāre ripping through āDazed and Confusedā you wonāt give a hoot.
āThereās more color and air in the NOS 76 mode.ā
If the NOS 75 circuit suffers by comparison to anything, itās the 2-transistor friend next door, the NOS 76. The lower-gain NOS 76 mode is, to my ears, the most appealing of the three. Itās the most dynamic in terms of touch response and guitar volume attenuation and delivers the clearest clean tones when you use either technique. Thereās more color and air in the NOS 76 mode, too. Paired with a neck-position single-coil, itās an excellent alternative for Hendrix and Eddie Hazel low-gain mellow fuzz thatās more like dirty overdrive. The silicon mode, meanwhile, lives on the modern borderlands of the ā60s-fuzz spectrum. Itās super-aggressive and focused, which can be really useful depending on the setting, but lo-fi, spitty, and weird when starved of voltage via the sag switch. Itās deviant-sounding stuff, but extends the Warm Benderās performance envelope in useful ways, particularly if you hunt for unique fuzz tones in the studio.
Thereās a widely accepted bit of wisdom that says most germanium fuzzes sound lousy unless you turn up everything all the way and use your guitar controls to tailor the tone. This is partly true, especially with a Fuzz Face. But in general, I respectfully disagree and present the Warm Bender as exhibit A in this defense. The gain and volume controls both have considerable range and fascinating shades of fuzz within that can still rise above the din of a raging band.
The Verdict
Some potential customers might balk at the notion of a $199 vintage-style fuzz made in Chinaāno matter how cool it looks. But the Warm Bender looks and feels well made. The sound and tactile sensations in the three circuits are truly different enough to be three individual effects, and $199 for three fuzz pedals is a sweet dealāparticularly when consolidated in a stompbox that looks this cool. There is a lot of variation in old Tone Benders, and how these takes on the circuits compare to your idea of true vintage Tone Bender sound will be subjective. But I heard the essence of both the MkI and MkII here very clearly and would have no qualms about using the Warm Bender in a session that called for an extra-authentic mid-ā60s fuzz texture.
Although inspired by the classic Fuzz Face, this stomp brings more to the hair-growth game with wide-ranging bias and low-cut controls.
One-ups the Fuzz Face in tonal versatility and pure, sustained filth, with the ability to preserve most of the natural sonic thumbprint of your guitar or take your tone to lower, delightfully nasty places.
Pushing the bias hard can create compromising note decay. Difficult to control at extreme settings.
$144
Catalinbread StarCrash
catalinbread.com
Filthy, saturated fuzz is a glorious thing, whether itās the writ-large solos of Big Brother and the Holding Companyās live āBall and Chain,ā the soaring feedback and pure crush of Jimi Hendrixās āFoxy Lady,ā or the sandblasted rhythm textures of Queens of the Stone Ageās āPaper Machete.ā Itās also a Wayback Machine. Step on a fuzz pedal and your tone is transported to the ā60s or early ā70s, which, when it comes to classic guitar sounds, is not a bad place to be.
Catalinbreadās StarCrash is from their new ā70s collection, so the company is laying its Six Million Dollar Man trading cards on the tableāupping the ante on traditional fuzz with more controls and, according to the companyās website, a little more volume than the average fuzz pedal, while still staying in the traditional Fuzz Face lane.
The Howlerās Viscera
Arbiter Electronics made the first Fuzz Face in 1966. The StarCrash is inspired by that 2-transistor pedal, but benefits from evolution, as did almost all fuzz pedals in the ā70s, when the standard shifted from germanium to silicon circuitry to improve the consistency of the effectās performance. The downside is that germanium is gnarlier to some ears, and silicon transistors donāt respond as well to adjustments made via a guitarās volume control.
While Fuzz Faces have only two knobs, volume and fuzz, the silicon StarCrash has three: volume, bias, and low-cut. Catalinbreadās website explains: āWe got rid of that goofy fuzz knob. We know that 95 percent of all players run it dimed, and the remaining 5 percent use their guitarās volume knob to rein it in.ā
I suspect there are plenty of players who, like me, do adjust the fuzz control on their pedals, but the most important thing is that the core fuzz sound here is excellentābristly and snarling, with a far girthier tone than my reissue Fuzz Face. Itās also, with the bias and low-cut controls, far more flexible. The low-cut control allows you to range from a traditional, comparatively thinner Fuzz Face sound (past noon and further) to the StarCrashās authentic, beefier voice (noon and lower). Essentially, it cuts bass frequencies from 40 Hz to 500 Hz, resulting in an aural menu that runs from lush and lowdown to buzzy and slicing. And the bias control is a direct route to the spitty, fragmented, so-called Velcro-sound thatās become a staple of the stoner-rock/Jack White school of tone. The company calls this dial a ādying battery simulator,ā and it starves the second transistor to achieve that effect.
Sweet Song of the Tribbles
Playing with the StarCrash is a lot of fun. I ran it through a pair of Carr amps in stereo, adding some delay and reverb to mood, and used a variety of single-coil- and humbucker-outfitted guitars. While both pickup types interacted well with the pedal, the humbuckers were most pleasing to my ears with the bias cranked to about 2 oāclock or higher, since the ābuckers higher output allowed me to let notes sustain longer before sputtering out. Keeping the low-cut filter at 9 oāclock or lower also helped sustain and depth in the Velcro-fuzz zone, while letting more of the instrumentsā natural voices come through, of course.
With the low-cut filter turned up full and the bias at 10 oāclock, I got the StarCrash to be the perfect doppelganger of my Hendrix reissue Fuzz Face. But thatās such a small part of the pedalās overall tone profile. It was more fun to roll off just a bit of bass and set the bias knob to about 2 or 3 oāclock. Around these settings, the sound is huge and grinding, and yet barre chords hold their character while playing rhythm, and single-note runs, especially on the low strings, are a filthy delight, with just the right schmear of buttery sustain plus a hint of decay lurking behind every note. Itās such a ripe toneāthe sonic equivalent of a delicious, stinky cheeseāthat I could hang with it all day.
Regarding Catalinbreadās claims about the volume control? Yes, it gets very loud without losing the essence of the notes or chords youāre playing, or the character of the fuzz, which is a distinct advantage when youāre in a band and need to stand out. And itās a tad louder than my Fuzz Face but doesnāt really bark up to the level of most Tone Bender or Buzzaround clones Iāve heard. In my experience, these germanium-chipped critters of similar vintage can practically slam you through the wall when their volume levels are cranked.
The Verdict
Catalinbreadās StarCrashāwith its sturdy enclosure, smooth on/off switch and easy-to-manipulate dialsācan compete with any Fuzz Face variant in both price and performance, scoring high points on the latter count. The bias and low-cut dials provide access to a wider-than-usual variety of fuzz tones, and are especially delightful for long, playful solos dappled with gristle, flutter, and sustain. Kudos to Catalinbread for making this pedal not just a reflection of the past, but an improvement on it.
Catalinbread Starcrash 70 Fuzz Pedal - Starcrash 70 Collection
StarCrash 70 Fuzz PedalA silicon Fuzz Face-inspired scorcher.
Hot silicon Fuzz Face tones with dimension and character. Sturdy build. Better clean tones than many silicon Fuzz Face clones.
Like all silicon Fuzz Faces, lacks dynamic potential relative to germanium versions.
$229
JAM Fuzz Phrase Si
jampedals.com
Everyone has records and artists they indelibly associate with a specific stompbox. But if the subject is the silicon Fuzz Face, my first thought is always of David Gilmour and the Pink Floyd: Live at Pompeii film. What you hear in Live at Pompeii is probably shaped by a little studio sweetening. Even still, the fuzz you hear in āEchoesā and āCareful With That Axe, Eugeneāāwell, that is how a fuzz blaring through a wall of WEM cabinets in an ancient amphitheater should sound, like the sky shredded by the wail of banshees. I donāt go for sounds of such epic scale much lately, but the sound of Gilmour shaking those Roman columns remains my gold standard for hugeness.
JAMās Fuzz Phrase Fuzz Face homage is well-known to collectors in its now very expensive and discontinued germanium version, but this silicon variation is a ripper. If you love Gilmourās sustaining, wailing buzzsaw tone in Pompeii, youāll dig this big time. But its ā66 acid-punk tones are killer, too, especially if you get resourceful with guitar volume and tone. And while it canāt match its germanium-transistor-equipped equivalent for dynamic response to guitar volume and tone settings or picking intensity, it does not have to operate full-tilt to sound cool. There are plenty of overdriven and near-clean tones you can get without ever touching the pedal itself.
Great Grape! Itās Purple JAM, Man!
Like any Fuzz Face-style stomp worth its fizz, the Fuzz Phrase Si is silly simple. The gain knob generally sounds best at maximum, though mellower settings make clean sounds easier to source. The output volume control ranges to speaker-busting zones. But thereās also a cool internal bias trimmer that can summon thicker or thin and raspy variations on the basic voice, which opens up the possibility of exploring more perverse fuzz textures. The Fuzz Phrase Siās pedal-to-the-metal tonesāwith guitar volume and pedal gain wide openābridge the gap between mid-ā60s buzz and more contemporary-sounding silicon fuzzes like the Big Muff. And guitar volume attenuation summons many different personalities from the Fuzz Phrase Siāfrom vintage garage-psych tones with more note articulation and less sustain (great for sharp, punctuated riffs) as well as thick overdrive sounds.
If youāre curious about Fuzz Face-style circuits because of the dynamic response in germanium versions, the Fuzz Phrase Si performs better in this respect than many other silicon variations, though it wonāt match the responsiveness of a good germanium incarnation. For starters, the travel you have to cover with a guitar volume knob to get tones approaching ācleanā (a very relative term here) is significantly greater than that required by a good germanium Fuzz Face clone, which will clean up with very slight guitar volume adjustments. This makes precise gain management with guitar controls harder. And in situations where you have to move fast, you may be inclined to just switch the pedal off rather than attempt a dirty-to-clean shift with the guitar volume.
āThe best clean-ish tones come via humbuckers and a high-headroom amp with not too much midrange, which makes a PAF-and-black-panel-Fender combination a great fit.ā
The best clean-ish tones come via humbuckers and a high-headroom amp with not too much midrange, which makes a PAF-and-black-panel-Fender combination a great fit if youāre out to extract maximum dirty-to-clean range. You donāt need to attenuate your guitar volume as much with the PAF/black-panel tandem, and you can get pretty close to bypassed tone if you reduce picking intensity and/or switch from flatpick to fingers and nails. Single-coil pickups make such maneuvers more difficult. They tend to get thin in a less-than-ideal way before they shake the dirt, and theyāre less responsive to the touch dynamics that yield so much range with PAFs. If youāre less interested in thick, clean tones, though, single-coils are a killer match for the Fuzz Phrase Si, yielding Yardbirds-y rasp, quirky lo-fi fuzz, and dirty overdrive that illuminates chord detail without sacrificing attitude. Pompeii tones are readily attainable via a Stratocaster and a high-headroom Fender amp, too, when you maximize guitar volume and pedal gain. And with British-style amps those same sounds turn feral and screaming, evoking Jimiās nastiest.
The Verdict
Like every JAM pedal Iāve ever touched, the JAM Fuzz Phrase Si is built with care that makes the $229 price palatable. Cheaper silicon Fuzz Face clones may be easy to come by, but Iām hard-pressed to think theyāll last as long or as well as the Greece-made Fuzz Phrase Si. Like any silicon Fuzz Face-inspired design, what you gain in heat, you trade in dynamics. But the Si makes the best of this trade, opening a path to near-clean tones and many in-between gain textures, particularly if you put PAFs and a scooped black-panel Fender amp in the mix. And if streamlining is on your agenda, this fuzzās combination of simplicity, swagger, and style means paring down pedals and controls doesnāt mean less fun.