Premier Guitar features affiliate links to help support our content. We may earn a commission on any affiliated purchases.

Bass Bench: Oil, Shellac, Nitro, Polyester, and Urethane: What Gives?

Bass Bench: Oil, Shellac, Nitro, Polyester, and Urethane: What Gives?
The long lines are cracks in the nitro finish, not the wood itself.

Let’s put the marketing hype aside and look at the basic properties of instrument finishes.

Previously, we launched an overview of the most common finishes used on basses, guitars, and other stringed instruments. If you missed this, check out “The World of Finishes.” Now let’s examine the pros and cons of these finishes and discover how they can influence tone.

We apply finish to a wooden instrument to protect it from physical damage, moisture, and other environmental influences. We also consider how it potentially affects tone and how it makes the instrument look and feel. While it’s easy to evaluate the degree of protection a finish can offer, it’s much harder to determine its influence on tone, especially because this impact can be masked by other factors. In addition to the thorny question of what constitutes good tone, we must address the differences between hollow acoustic instruments and solidbody electrics—a big task for one column.

Good tone is often defined as “rich,” meaning that almost every vibration of a string gets converted into an acoustic or electric signal with minimal loss and conversion to heat. Rich tone isn’t always what we’re looking for in a specific song, but let’s remember that while it’s possible to filter something out, we can’t add something that’s not there.

Okay, given these basic concepts, what can an oil finish do for us? In a forum, one luthier unleashed a storm of controversy when he stated that oil is the most amateur finish, and he couldn’t call anyone a pro who works this way. Those who didn’t own a spray booth vehemently disagreed, but he was generally right. An oil finish offers zero protection against physical damage, except for a minimal amount if it’s mixed with a resin that cures and hardens over time. Several studies have compared the tonal differences between untreated and oiled wood, and the outcome was that all oils had a dampening effect on sound. The only essential criterion oil doesn’t fail is protection from moisture. Look and feel are subjective, so for some, oil can score well in that department.

As opposed to oil, shellac varnishes harden on top of the wood grain, adding mechanical stability and therefore physical protection. And because, unlike oil, they don’t seep into the wood grain, they don’t produce a dampening effect. Shellac layers are thin, so they help keep an acoustic soundboard light, allowing it to deliver a more dynamic, lively, and louder tone than heavier finishes. So, assuming you don’t mind having resin secreted by a lac beetle covering your instrument, a shellac finish offers sonic benefits, as well as some protection.

Unlike the thick polyester coatings of yesteryear, modern finishes can now be applied as thin but hard layers that still retain enough flexibility to resist cracking as the wood “works.”

The same is true for nitrocellulosefinishes, but both shellac and nitro share the problem of adding only a minimal degree of mechanical rigidity, i.e., physical protection. Nitro finishes can be pretty hard, but in a thin layer it’s often the substrate that defines the overall hardness, so movements within the wood soon lead to cracks (Image 1) and thus reduced protection from moisture.

There’s a popular notion (even among some luthiers) that thin nitro finishes allow the wood to “breathe.” This seems positive because the term sounds so natural and alive. But it’s a fallacy: The tree is long dead and nitro was developed with the intention of keeping oxygen away from the metal surface of automotive parts. So much for breathing.

Other reasons why nitro gets so much praise: (1) It was used in the heyday of the electric guitar and bass, and (2) its successor was polyester, applied by chemically untrained workers. These workers applied nitro about 10 times to an instrument to give it a finish, so that’s how they worked with polyester. But because polyester has a much higher percentage of solids, this resulted in very thick and durable—yet slightly softer—layers that dampened vibration more than nitro—especially in the higher registers.

Once the finishers learned how to work with polyester, its reputation was already established and the first urethanes appeared. And that’s also when things got more complicated. Modern urethane finishes consist of two components—a basic resin (polyol) and a hardener or activator (polyisocyanate)—and the types and amounts of these two components affect the surface’s final properties, like hardness, elasticity, and scratch resistance. The two main resins used to create polyurethane are often categorized into acrylic and polyester. Though the former preceded the latter, we can’t say one is better than the other—it’s a finish’s formulation that determines its functionality. Most of the confusion here comes from marketing departments trying to set their products apart from the competition without using correct terminology. But let’s get back to what all this means for our instruments before the chemistry police show up.

Unlike the thick polyester coatings of yesteryear, modern finishes can now be applied as thin but hard layers that still retain enough flexibility to resist cracking as the wood “works.” And these new finishes are less toxic to work with than nitro, and they’re impervious to UV light and almost any solvent. So why do we still see so much nitro in advertising? Simply because “vintage vibe” sells, whether there’s a poly layer underneath or almost no nitro in the final finish. Ah, the power of buzzwords.


- YouTube

Join PG contributor Tom Butwin as he explores all-new versions of the Framus Hootenanny 12-string and 6-string acoustics—made famous by John Lennon and now available with modern upgrades. From vintage-inspired tone to unique features, these guitars are built to spark creativity.

Neil Young’s ’70s hits are some of the most recognizable radio rock jams of all time. But Neil’s guitar playing continued to grow over the ensuing decades, as he traversed styles from blues to country to electronic to rockabilly and beyond, eventually developing one of the most tonally decadent, fully formed improvisational voices in the entire guitar universe.

Read MoreShow less

This Japan-made Guyatone brings back memories of hitchin’ rides around the U.S.

This oddball vintage Guyatone has a streak of Jack Kerouac’s adventurous, thumbing spirit.

The other day, I saw something I hadn’t noticed in quite some time. Driving home from work, I saw an interesting-looking fellow hitchhiking. When I was a kid, “hitchers” seemed much more common, but, then again, the world didn’t seem as dangerous as today. Heck, I can remember hitching to my uncle’s cabin in Bradford, Pennsylvania—home of Zippo lighters—and riding almost 200 miles while I sat in a spare tire in the open bed of a pickup truck! Yes, safety wasn’t a big concern for kids back in the day.

Read MoreShow less

There's a lot of musical gold inside the scales.

Intermediate

Intermediate

• Develop a deeper improvisational vocabulary.

• Combine pentatonic scales to create new colors.

• Understand the beauty of diatonic harmony.
{'file_original_url': 'https://roar-assets-auto.rbl.ms/documents/11372/OneChordVamp-Jul21.pdf', 'id': 11372, 'media': '[rebelmouse-document-pdf 11372 site_id=20368559 original_filename="OneChordVamp-Jul21.pdf"]', 'media_html': 'OneChordVamp-Jul21.pdf', 'type': 'pdf'}

Improvising over one chord for long stretches of time can be a musician's best friend or worst nightmare. With no harmonic variation, we are left to generate interest through our lines, phrasing, and creativity. When I started learning to improvise, a minor 7 chord and a Dorian mode were the only sounds that I wanted to hear at the time. I found it tremendously helpful to have the harmony stay in one spot while I mined for new ideas to play. Playing over a static chord was crucial in developing my sense of time and phrasing.

Read MoreShow less