Premier Guitar features affiliate links to help support our content. We may earn a commission on any affiliated purchases.

Tone Bakery Creme Brulee Review

Superb “klone” tones on the cheap.

No matter how you feel about the Klon Centaur—whether you share the near-religious reverence of its acolytes or simply shrug your shoulders—it’s a damn fine and mighty versatile overdrive. And as with any good (or excruciatingly rare and expensive) pedal, it’s nice to have affordable alternatives.

Tone Bakery’s Creme Brulee doesn’t promise anything apart from being an affordable Klon alternative. But at 99 bucks, it’s very affordable by the near-mad standards of the vintage Klon market. And it delivers much of the Klon’s transparent, near-clean-to-crunchy tones, while offering the responsiveness that spawned the great Klon craving in the first place.

Slightly Secret Sauce
With gain, treble, and level controls aligned along the pedal’s length and an offset footswitch, the Creme Brulee hints unabashedly at the source of its inspiration. Alas, you won’t find out a lot about the Creme Brulee’s components by opening up the back. The upside-down printed circuit reveals even less than the black-tar goop that cloaks the innards of a real Klon. You can, however, see some of the cost saving measures that help Tone Bakery get below the $100 mark, such as board-mounted jacks. We also noticed that the unit can be a bit microphonic and susceptible to switching noise and bumps at high-gain settings, suggesting it could use a little extra shielding somewhere in the circuit.

Reactivity is enhanced by an overdriven signal that doesn’t color your guitar’s output too much.

In general though, economical construction methods have little adverse effect on the unit’s sturdy, solid feel. The knobs turn with a satisfying resistance that allows precise adjustments from the toe of a boot, and they tend to stay in place once you’ve got them where you want them.

Send in the Klones
If you plugged in the Creme Brulee and dialed everything up to noon, you’d probably be pretty pleased with the muscle and dimension it stacks on top of your amplified signal. It’s a fat, full, and natural-sounding overdrive. It’s also a Klon clone, so it was hard to resist playing it alongside the real deal—in this case, Senior Editor Joe Gore’s original (serial number 309 for all you pedal-spotters out there).

How did the Creme Brulee hold up against its near-mythical inspiration? Remarkably well, all told. Perhaps the most important difference is in the pedal’s touch sensitivity. While there’s not a profound difference between the Klon and the Creme Brulee, notes from the Klon tend to jump just a bit more immediately from the amp, and the output from the Creme Brulee feels a touch more compressed at equivalent settings. The difference is subtle, and it’s unlikely to affect the way you interact with the pedal, unless you’re obsessed with technique or a hyper-shredder. (And if that’s the case, why are you looking at a budget overdrive anyway?)

Ratings

Pros:
Super-authentic Klon-style tones on the cheap. Wide range of overdrive colors.

Cons:
Microphonic at high-gain settings.

Tones:

Ease of Use:

Build/Design:

Value:

Street:
$99

Tone Bakery Creme Brulee
tonebakery.com

In fact, were the Creme Brulee not hooked up next to the original Klon, we probably wouldn’t notice any lack of attack at all. It’s sensitive to picking dynamics, and that reactivity is enhanced by an overdriven signal that doesn’t color your guitar’s output too much. Like the Klon, the Creme Brulee possesses a subtlety at low-gain settings that some might classify as transparent—especially when you roll back the gain to near zero. And the ability it gives you to move between wildly different guitars and hear a clear, more-muscular version of each instrument lends a real sense of musical flexibility and dynamism that expands tone and performance possibilities in the studio and on the stage.

Adding gain in small doses colors guitar and amplifier tones with the same airy, wide-spectrum amp-like overdrive that made the Klon intoxicating to so many. And the range of available overdrive shades sometimes feels as colorful and full of possibilities as a box of 64 new Crayolas. Single-coils delivered everything from venomous blues tones to “Taxman”-style Beatle sounds, depending on how you set the very versatile treble control. Humbuckers bristled with cool, compressed, extra high-mid content that lent definition to arpeggios and power chords.

The Creme Brulee’s breadth of character is apparent in higher gain settings too—an application for which Klon’s are less celebrated, perhaps, but at which they are no less capable. The pedal can transform medium-wattage Fenders and 18-watt Marshalls into punky beasts with half-stack-like ferocity. And the snappy picky sensitivity you hear in feel in these zones is intoxicating stuff—particularly if you’ve been binge listening to the works of the young Jimmy Page.

The Verdict
Taken alone, there’s very little downside to the Creme Brulee. Perhaps the most glaring flaw is a lack of shielding that can make the pedal as microphonic as a vintage germanium fuzz at high-gain settings. Then again, the percentage of players who’ll use the Creme Brulee in that way are probably in the minority. That shortcoming aside, the Creme Brulee does a startlingly good imitation of an original Klon, and the slight differences in touch sensitivity, dynamics (the Creme Brulee has a little less), and compression (the Creme Brulee has a little more) are really only perceptible when you play it alongside a vintage Klon. For the rest of us, the Creme Brulee is an excellent overdrive alternative that offers a riot of gritty colors at a very reasonable price.

Watch the Review Demo:

Complex tremolo sounds combine in stereo fields that can sound more like underwater swimming than swamp-rocking.

Lovely washes of complex tremolo textures that can be spread across a stereo field. High-quality build. Useful stereo pan control. Practical boost control.

High depth settings could be more intense for some voices. Some harmonic/optical blends can be subtle, compromising their essence.

$279

Walrus Monumental Harmonic Stereo Tremolo
walruspedals.com

4.5
4.5
4.5
4

Among fellow psychedelic music-making chums in the ’90s, few tools were quite as essential as a Boss PN-2 Tremolo Pan. Few of us had two amplifiers with which we could make use of one. But if you could borrow an amp, you could make even the lamest riff sound mind-bending.

Read MoreShow less

An unusual, intuitive amalgam of sustain pedal, looper, delay, and modulator that can be a mellow harmonizer, a chaos machine, and many things in between.

Easy-to-conjure unique-sounding, complex waves of sound, or subtle, swelling background harmonies. Intuitive operation, including secondary functions.

Many possible voices begs for presets.

$229

MXR Layers
jimdulop.com

4
4.5
4
4.5

It’s unclear whether the unfortunate term “shoegaze” was coined to describe a certain English indie subculture’s proclivity for staring at pedals, or their sometimes embarrassed-at-performing demeanor. The MXR Layers will, no doubt, find favor among players that might make up this sect, as well as other ambience-oriented stylists. But it will probably leave players of all stripes staring floorward, too, at least while they learn the ropes with this addictive mashup of delay, modulation, harmonizer, and sustain effects.

Read MoreShow less

A twist on the hard-to-find Ibanez MT10 that captures the low-gain responsiveness of the original and adds a dollop of more aggressive sounds too.

Excellent alternative to pricey, hard-to-find, vintage Mostortions. Flexible EQ. Great headroom. Silky low-gain sounds.

None.

$199

Wampler Mofetta
wamplerpedals.com

5
5
5
4.5

Wampler’s new Mofetta is a riff on Ibanez’s MT10 Mostortion, a long-ago discontinued pedal that’s now an in-demand cult classic. If you look at online listings for the MT10, you’ll see that asking prices have climbed up to $1k in extreme cases.

Read MoreShow less

Although inspired by the classic Fuzz Face, this stomp brings more to the hair-growth game with wide-ranging bias and low-cut controls.

One-ups the Fuzz Face in tonal versatility and pure, sustained filth, with the ability to preserve most of the natural sonic thumbprint of your guitar or take your tone to lower, delightfully nasty places.

Pushing the bias hard can create compromising note decay. Difficult to control at extreme settings.

$144

Catalinbread StarCrash
catalinbread.com

4
4
4
4


Read MoreShow less