Premier Guitar features affiliate links to help support our content. We may earn a commission on any affiliated purchases.

Acoustic or Electric? You Don’t Have to Choose

Spreading the love equally between electric and acoustic

I started playing the guitar when I was about eight or nine years old. My brothers and I used to bowl in a kids’ league every Saturday, then we’d rush home to watch The Monkees on the local station that afternoon. I always looked forward to the song segment of the show so that I could hear the music and watch them play. I’d also hear their stuff on the radio along with the Beatles, and had many debates with neighborhood kids over which band was better. Sometimes we’d even ponder if the Archies weren’t in fact the best band!

With all of that curiosity in this magical thing called music, I asked my mom for a guitar that Christmas. Naturally, I had dreams of getting the same sparkle-finished Gretsch electric guitar complete with whammy bar that I saw Mike Nesmith holding on TV, but I was just as excited to find an inexpensive Bradley acoustic from the Sears catalogue under the tree that year. To me, it was every bit as cool as the Gretsch would have been.

At that young age, I never made a distinction between acoustic and electric playing. The electrics were louder and cooler looking, but a guitar was a guitar, so I started playing my little knock-off acoustic and loved it. My elementary school offered free lessons to fifth and sixth graders who wanted to stay after school to learn, so naturally I started lugging my no-name axe to school once a week to learn a handful of chords and fingerpicking patterns right out of the Peter, Paul & Mary and Bob Dylan songbooks. It really gave me a solid base on acoustic before I moved on to the neverending challenge of electric guitar. Once I got my tiny hands on an electric, I focused on banging out barre chords and pentatonic scale-based riffs, but never lost sight of how much I enjoyed playing my old acoustic, too.

When I was 15, I bought a Guild D-55 acoustic and just fell in love with how big and powerful an acoustic guitar could sound. I’m sure one of the first things I played on it was the opening progression to Led Zeppelins’ classic “Stairway To Heaven.” It was the first time that something I played sounded exactly like the original recording, and my love affair with the acoustic was rekindled. As I listened to more and more true acoustic players, I started to find that they were doing things on the guitar that were so much more complicated and challenging to learn to play than the electric stuff was. I was baffled. Everyone knows that Jimi Hendrix was a better player than James Taylor, so how could that stuff be harder? When I was in high school, some of the struggle of learning these acoustic pieces was lifted when I discovered that many of these songs were being played using an “open tuning,” like dropped C (C-GC- F-A-D) or open G (D-G-D-G-B-D). All of a sudden, those songs with impossible reaches became quite easily playable using the open strings in their altered tuning.

One of my favorite acoustic players is a Nashville session “A-lister” named Billy Joe Walker, Jr. His album Treehouse was an inspiration to me as a writer of acoustic guitar music. Around that same time I discovered the group Acoustic Alchemy. Their album Red Dust & Spanish Lace contained wonderful compositions for acoustic guitar, like “Mr. Chow” and “The Rideout.” They led me to realize that acoustic guitar is not just relegated to the hands of the “chick singer” in a Country/Western duo, or the second banana type who couldn’t quite master the electric. It was in fact a full-blown animal of its own, and an important part of any band.

Around 1999, I began what has been a very rewarding relationship with the people at Taylor guitars. With so many instruments in their line to choose from, I find that they have an acoustic for any occasion. The first guitar I picked up from them was a Taylor 514ce. This Grand Auditorium model was designed with a smaller body size to be best used for fingerstyle guitar. I immediately recognized that it was appropriate for any style of playing, picking or strumming. I also have a Taylor 610ce, which Taylor boasts can be used for any number of applications—and they were right. I primarily use it when I need to be the “tuned maraca” and lock in with the drummer as a strong driving force in the rhythm section. It also shines when I need to be out front, carrying the melody.

Don’t get me wrong. There’s nothing better than standing down front with your toes hanging over the front of the stage, cranking out some max-overdriven Nugent-esque riff at 126dB to a crowd of screaming fans. But sometimes it’s nice to be able to deliver a pure heartfelt melody on acoustic, too.

Keep Jammin’.

Rich Eckhardt
Rich Eckhardt is one of the most sought after guitarists in Nashville. His ability to cover multiple styles has put him on stage with singers ranging from Steven Tyler of Aerosmith to Shania Twain. Rich is currently playing lead guitar with Toby Keith. His album Soundcheck is available now, with another due this summer.

Alex LIfeson, Victor

Anthem Records in Canada and Rhino Records will reissue the first-ever solo albums of Rush's Alex Lifeson and Geddy Lee. Lifeson’s 1996 album Victor and Lee’s 2000 offering My Favourite Headache will be re-released on August 9, 2024.

Read MoreShow less

The "Sandblasted" SE Series features a swamp ash top with a unique sandblasted finish in five color options.

Read MoreShow less

We’re unpacking Reid’s playing—from his early days in the NYC jazz underground through his work with Living Colour and into supergroup superstardom—and his longstanding gear-acquisition-syndrome.

Read MoreShow less
Fall Out Boy Rig Rundown [2024]
Fall Out Boy Rig Rundown with Patrick Stump, Joe Trohman & Pete Wentz Guitar & Bass Gear Tour

The string-section trio for the iconic Chicago pop-punk band has gone digital, but Patrick Stump, Joe Trohman, and Pete Wentz still aren’t afraid to get weird—and sometimes, downright dangerous.

Read MoreShow less