Premier Guitar features affiliate links to help support our content. We may earn a commission on any affiliated purchases.

Jol Dantzig’s Esoterica Electrica: What’s the Tonewood Equivalent of Gold?

Jol Dantzig’s Esoterica Electrica: What’s the Tonewood Equivalent of Gold?
Our columnist notes: “The sonic fingerprint of mahogany may be a matter of tradition as much as anything else.”

Easy to work with, beautiful, stable, and much more, the marvel of mahogany isn’t lost on luthiers. But the price is a different story.

Nearly 50 years ago, renowned luthier Richard Bruné opened his storefront workshop three blocks from my home. I’d occasionally stop inside to marvel at all the wood and tools, and ask a few naïve questions. I had already started repairing and setting up guitars, but hadn’t considered the idea of making one from scratch. Still, it was fascinating to see that someone could make a living building guitars. The practice certainly wasn’t as prevalent as it is today.

Inside the workshop, cedar, cypress, and rosewood boards were stacked up neatly, along with Honduras mahogany blanks used for necks. I recognized the medium-brown mahogany wood as being the same wood used for the body and neck of my 1952 Les Paul, but that seemed the only thing that linked my electric with the flamenco instruments Bruné specialized in. I’d never thought about why the type of wood could make a difference, but Bruné certainly did. I think it was also the first time I’d heard the term “tonewood.”

It might be science. Now, it seems obvious that stringed instruments rely upon the properties of their wood for their sound. If you don’t believe that, try stretching a guitar string with your hands while someone plucks it. Or you could just play a brass-bodied resonator guitar for comparison.

There is solid scientific evidence that volume and timbre are affected by a material’s flexural modulus and its mass. Stiff, dense materials (mostly for tops, but also backs and sides) can be made thinner to reduce weight, which increases response to vibration. The quicker response puts emphasis on the attack of the note, whereas a less dense wood may tend to favor a gentler rise to volume. This is an oversimplification, but serves as an illustration as to how a builder might select different wood species to tailor an instrument’s sound.

Following tradition. Not long after my chats with Bruné, I had the opportunity to help construct a bass for myself in repairman John Montgomery’s basement shop. By then, I’d noted the difference between many of the woods that the major guitar manufacturers used. And when I decided to build a circa-1967 Flying V-style bass, it seemed natural to choose mahogany and rosewood like the Gibson EB-3 I already owned. I liked the look and sound of that instrument, so it was a matter of convention, I suppose. I later learned that there was a lot more to a guitar’s sound than just wood and pickups, but that’s where I started. So, why did Gibson (and others) choose mahogany for so many of their instruments?

Because genuine mahogany was harvested ruthlessly for several centuries, it is now highly regulated, and almost all that’s available is plantation grown.

Chicken or egg? Many of the early manufacturers were no doubt influenced by several factors. Mahogany has long been considered a premium wood, especially in furniture. Genuine mahogany (Swietenia macrophylla), sometimes called Honduras mahogany, possesses a rich brown color and captivating grain structure that lends an air of quality to any instrument based upon appearance alone. Mahogany is also a joy to work with whether using machines or hand tools, and is also extremely stable. It takes a finish more easily than oily woods like rosewood, which also helps make it an obvious favorite of furniture and guitar makers.

It may be these practical factors that led Gibson and Martin to substitute mahogany for the more expensive rosewood in downscale acoustics, and likewise in their inherently less-costly electric models. The aura of mahogany as a so-called “tonewood” may have been a marketing device used to position instruments above more pedestrian guitars using domestic woods like maple, ash, and alder. As such, the sonic fingerprint of mahogany may be a matter of tradition as much as anything else.

Scarcity and desirability. Since the late 1700s, mahogany from South America has been highly prized for shipbuilding, furniture, homes, and musical instruments. Mahogany trees in the wild grow slowly, achieving heights as tall as 200 feet and yielding boards several feet in width. Because genuine mahogany was harvested ruthlessly for several centuries, however, it is now highly regulated, and almost all that’s available is plantation grown.

Despite large increases in costs, some instrument makers have noted a decline in the quality of the plantation-grown mahogany, yet it continues to be a staple. Others have looked to alternatives such as okume, obeche, and khaya (referred to as African mahogany), as well as domestic woods like maple and walnut. Old-growth mahogany boards still surface, and are extremely desirable, but have also become insanely expensive.

Given the success of instruments built from readily available materials such as ash, poplar, alder, and even pine, it is uncertain if mahogany instruments will retain their air of superiority in the future. Certainly, guitarists who favor classic-style upscale guitars will continue to favor the beauty of mahogany, while perhaps not enjoying the price. For those who feel that tonewoods are a myth, the future is boundless. As far as the difference in sound is concerned, the answers are highly personal and will be debated for years to come. What’s certain is that mahogany in some form is here to stay, as is the word tonewood.


While Annie Clark was named the 26th greatest guitarist of all time by Rolling Stone in 2023, she couldn’t care less about impressing an athletic stamp on either her sound or her image.


Photo by Alex Da Corte

On her eighth studio release, the electroacoustic art-rock guitarist and producer animates an extension of the strange and singular voice she’s been honing since her debut in 2007.

“Did you grow up Unitarian?” Annie Clark asks me. We’re sitting in a control room at Electric Lady Studios in New York’s West Village, and I’ve just explained my personal belief system to her, to see if Clark, aka St. Vincent, might relate and return the favor. After all, does she not possess a kind of sainthood worth inquiring about?

Read MoreShow less

The GibsonES Supreme Collection (L-R) in Seafoam Green, Bourbon Burst, and Blueberry Burst.

The new Gibson ES Supreme offers AAA-grade figured maple tops, Super Split Block inlays, push/pull volume controls, and Burstbucker pickups.

Read MoreShow less

Mdou Moctar has led his Tuareg crew around the world, but their hometown performances in Agadez, Niger, last year were their most treasured.

Photo by Ebru Yildiz

On the Tuareg band’s Funeral for Justice, they light a fiery, mournful pyre of razor-sharp desert-blues riffs and political calls to arms.

Mdou Moctar, the performing moniker of Tuareg guitar icon Mahamadou “Mdou” Souleymane, has played some pretty big gigs. Alongside guitarist Ahmoudou Madassane, drummer Souleymane Ibrahim, and bassist Mikey Coltun, Moctar has led his band’s kinetic blend of rock, psych, and Tuareg cultural traditions like assouf and takamba to Newport Folk Festival, Pitchfork Music Festival, and, just this past April, to the luxe fields of Indio, California, for Coachella. Off-kilter indie-rock darlings Parquet Courts brought them across the United States in 2022, after which they hit Europe for a run of headline dates.

Read MoreShow less

U.S.-made electronics and PRS’s most unique body profile make this all-American S2 a feast of tones at a great price.

Many sonic surprises. Great versatility. Excellent build quality

The pickup selector switch might be in a slightly awkward position for some players.

$2,029

PRS S2 Vela
prsguitars.com

4.5
5
5
4.5

Since its introduction in 2013, PRS’s S2 range has worked to bridge the gap between the company’s most affordable and most expensive guitars. PRS’s cost-savings strategy for the S2 was simple. The company fitted U.S.-made bodies and necks, built using the more streamlined manufacturing processes of PRS’s Stevensville 2 facility, with Asia-made electronics from the SE line.

Read MoreShow less